Dewester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2013 6:30 PM To: Hite, Richard; Lorah, Wiliiam; Cunningham, Vaferie; Price, Michael Netting. Ted W. Cc: Bieberich, Gregory F. Subject: Tris: Daily 'Summary Attachments: Bisard Triaf Summarydocx See attached triai sum mary I David Bisard Trial Summary One juror was excluded after he informed the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from Indianapolis stating he had a relative on IMPD and stated that Bisard is guilty and Indy cops drink a lot. He also said that Bisard's wife left him just before the crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Summarv: I Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking traffic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. I Sheila Beisel (MCSD Communication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications system (CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. 0 Barbara Belt Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Jennifer Westfall Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed" and did observe lights I siren) In Lisa Meyer Described witnessing the crash and rendering aid (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) 0 Samantha Daniels . Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) 4- Tamiea Franklin Described witnessing the crash 0 Senobia Pervine (IMPD Victim Assistance) Described her interactions at the scene with the unhuzt victim who did advise hearing a siren. 0 Dana Douing Paramedic (l\/Iedic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on the scene 0 Dennis Dorsey EMT (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on scene David Bisard .0 Todd Ward" (Lawrence Fire Dept. EMT) Described treating Eric Wells Logistics Off. Harman was 1'eleai?ed and returned. to Indy Dewester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich, Gregory Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 6:23 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory I-lite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Netting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summary.docx See attached triai summary Day 2 David Bisard Trial Summ Witness Summary: 0 Barbara Miller (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. I April Sohn (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signsof intoxication. 0 Dr. anice Billings (Family doctor of Kurt Weekly Mary Mills) Described treating Mary and Kurt after the accident 0 Dr. Bryan Haag (Methodist Hospital surgeon) Described treating Mary Mills in the ER 0 Dr. Tim Pohlman (Methodist Hospital ER doctor) Described treating Kurt Weekly Kurt Weekly Described his injuries 0 Mary Mills Described her injuries Luisa Mon-tilla (Eric Well's wife) Talked about Wells - George Burk (uninjured Described the events of the crash 0 Officer Thomas Stout (MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. He checked all victims and briefly spoke to Bisard, who was distraught. No signs of intoxication. - Officer-Brad Millikan (Robbery/Former MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. Bisard was upset, kneeling over Mr. Weekly talking to him. Millikan is a fatal certified accident investigator, called for an ET, and asked Bisard for a quick statement. Bisard said he was westbound and looked down, then looked back up and it was too late. Bisard also said his brakes locked up and he had been to the garage for a brake issue earlier in the day. Millikan is a breath test operator also, and he detected no signs of intoxication. D'-WidBiSarr3ummaY Logistics: Trial is ahead of schedule based on prosecution witness scheduling. Both ofiieers were released to 1'eturn to Indy David Bisard Trial Summ One juror was excluded after he infonned the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from Indianapolis stating he had a relative on IMPD and stated that Bisard is guilty and Indy cops drink a lot. He also said that Bisard's wife left him just before the crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Summarv: 0 Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking traffic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. 0 Sheila Beisel (MCSD Communication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications system (CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. 0 Barbara Belt . Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Jennifer Westfall Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Lisa Meyer Described witnessing the crash and rendering aid (excessive speed and did observe fights I siren) - Samantha Daniels Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Tamica Franklin Described witnessing the crash Senobia Pcrvine (IMPD Victim Assistance) Described her interactions at the scene with the unhurt victim who did advise hearing a siren. Dana Douing Paramedic (Medic 24) Described" treating Ms. Mills on the scene 0 Dennis Dorsey EMT (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on scene David Bisard Ta] Sumfy Todd Ward (Lawrence Fire Dept. EMT) Described treating Eric Wells Logistics: Off Harman was released andret111'ned to Indy Dewester, Samantha E. Bieberich, Gregory F. From: Sent: Friday, October 2013 6:26 PM To: Bieberich. Gregory 53.; Hits, Richard; Lorah, Wiiliam; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Noiting, Ted -W. Subject: RE: Triai Dairy Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summary.docx See attached trial summary Day 3 Did Bisar Trial Sumary Witness Summary: Assistant Chief Ron Hicks Responded to the scene without lights and siren. interacted with Bisarcl briefly 3 times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes be attributed to the air bag deployment. Commander John Carney Responded to the scene without lights and siren. interacted with Bisard several times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Explained the policy related to vehicle response types (emergency, non-emergency response) Darryl Pierce Responded to the -scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard several times over the period of several -minutes. Did not see signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Talked about the pursuit and vehicle operations general orders. Said a response to a felony arrest warrant did not rise to an emergency response level regardless of the position of the officer. The defense began to ask about his meeting with the Chief and Director after leaving the scene, but the prosecution objected, and the question was withdrawn after all parties approached the bench. Daniel Ryan (K9 officer) v' Described responding to the scene running with red lights and siren afier being informed by another officer that Bisard was involved in an accident. He said he drove up to 80 MPH on the highway and was using his computer. Described the K9 response to a possible felony marijuana warrant as an "urgent" run that was appropriate for an emergency response using red iights and siren. He said that running 10-39 is up to officer discretion. He said it is "normal" for officers to operate the in-car computer while driving under emergency conditions, and there are no policies governing that. He said that the K9 unit runs day shift with a minimum staffing of 2 dogs, but that is not always followed. He advised that it was not inappropriate for Bisard to respond to that run under emergency conditions. He advised that," during a phone call two days later, Bisard told-him that he worried about the results of the blood draw showing residual alcohol from his 'x consumption of alcohol on the night before the crash. He said that Bisard told him that he did not get drunk, but was drinking. He did not detect signs of intoxication in Bisard on the scene. He advised that Bisard told him during another phone call several months later that he had been drinking vodka on the night before the crash. I Shawn Dent (Regional Director of Methodist Dccupational Health) Described the blood draw policy of the agency 0 Sgt. Jeff Paterson (MNE. Sgt.) Described responding to the scene, interacting with Bisard, and driving him to Methodist Occupational Health. "He did not detect signs of alcohol use. 0 Lt.- Benny Diggs Testifled he met Bisa-rd at Methodist Occupational, saw the blood draw, then" went to roll call with Bisard. They then Went to Shapiros for lunch, then he drove him to the garage to get a pool vehicle. He did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. 0 Dr. Saj Alex (Dr. at Methodist Occupational Health) Described his treatment-of Bisard. He did not detect any signs of intoxication. Logistics: Sgt. Horn arrived and learned that the prosecution decided to postpone his testimony until next week. He then returned to Indy. All other personnel called as witnessestestified and returned to Indy. David BisardTrial Summary adiSI'dTFia15uma Witness Summary: Barbara Miller (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. April Sohn (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. Dr. Janice Billings (Family doctor of Kurt Weekly Mary' Mills) Described treating Mary and Kurt after the accident 'Dr. Bryan Haag (l\/Iethodist Hospital surgeon) Described treating Mary Mills. in the ER Dr. Tim Pohlman (Methodist Hospital ER doctor) Described treating Kurt Weekly Kurt Weekly Described his injuries Mary Mills Described her injuries Luisa Montilla (Eric Well's wife) Talked about Wells George Burk (uninjured Described the events of the crash Officer Thomas Stout (NIND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. He checked all victims and briefly spoke to Bisard, who was distraught. No signs of intoxication. Officer Brad Millikan (Robbery I Former MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. Bisard was upset, kneeling over Mr. Weekly talking to him. Millikan is a fatal certified accident investigator, called for an ET, and asked Bisard for a quick statement. Bisard said he was westbound and looked down, then looked back up and it was too late. Bisard also said his brakes locked up and he had been to the garage for a brake issue earlier in the day. Millikan is a breath test operator also, and he detected no signs of intoxication. avid Bisard Tril ulnar Logisfics: Trial is ahead of schedule based on prosecution witness scheduling. Both officers were released to return to Indy David Bisrd Trial Suary One juror was excluded after he informed the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from -Indianapolis stating he had a relative on IMP-D and stated that Bisard is_ guilty and Indy' cops drink a lot. He also said that Bi'sard's wife left him just before the crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Summarv: 0 Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking traffic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. 0 Sheila Beisel (MCSD Communication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications system (CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. 0 Barbara Belt Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Jennifer Westfall Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Lisa Meyer . Described_witne$SiI1g the crash and rendcring_ aid (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Samantha Daniels Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) a Tamica Franklin Described witnessing the crash 0 Senobia Pervine (IMPD Victim Assistance) Described her interactions at the scene with the unhurt victim who did advise hearing a siren. 0 Dana Douing Paramedic (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on the scene 0 Dennis Dorsey EMT (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on scene I Todd Ward (Lawrence Fire Dept. EMT) Described treating Eric Wells Logistics: Off. Harman was releasecl and returned to Indy D3 Dewester, Samantha E. Bieberich, Gregory From: Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 6:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory 19.; Hits, Richard; Lo-rah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. RE: Trial Daily Summary Subject: Bisard Trial Summamdocx Attachments: See attached trial summary Day 4 bait;-5 DVidBiSaria1SuarY Witness Summary: 0 Michelle Johnson (Magda) (Methodist Occupational Health' Center Medical Assistant) 1/ 1/ Described taking Bisard's blood sample. Followed MOHC protocol, but Lt. Stevenson wanted her to follow the protocol of chain of custody and handling the blood viles. The blood viles on hand were expired, and new viles had to be brought in. She aecidently wiped Bisard's right arm with an alcohol swab. She cleaned the arm and her hands, threw out all testing equipment, got new equipment and took "blood from his left arm. She handed the viles directly to Lt. Stevens who took possession of them. She said she did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. The defense attacked her procedures as not following MOHC protocol. 0 Dr. Joyce Carter (Chief Forensic Pathologist for Marion v' She described Eric Wells' fatal wounds 0 Stan Stevens (Former LPD lieutenant) The defense was prohibited from getting into the facts of Stevens' separation frorn LPD . in front of the jury. v' v' 'x He was paged as part' of FACT Team 6, and went "to" MOI-IC to witness the blood draw and take possession of the blood. - He asked Michelle if she was certified to take the blood, and she replied that she was. He labeled the viles and took possession of them after the blood draw. He left MOHC with the blood viles in his pocket and walked to Hardees for 15-20 minutes before going to the property room. He detected no signs of "alcohol consumption by Bisard. He advised that he did not see Michelle invert the viles 8 times after drawing the blood (as the protocol calls for). He advised that he filled out his paperwork incorrectly when stating that Michelle drew the blood from Bisard's right arm (the arm that the alcohol pad. was used on) instead of his left arm. He described the process of checking the viles into the IMPD property room. - Rick Winningham (Indianapolis Fleet Services) Is the keeper of records and introduced the title to Bisard's vehicle, and the repair report generated for that vehicle Damadilsummrr 0 Ken Simpson (Mechanic for Indianapolis Fleet Services) Described doing the preventative maintenance and brake work on Bi sard's car on the morning of the crash. He replaced the brake pads on his car, ordered other parts, and released the vehicle back' to him in a safe condition. He did not detect intoxication in the hour plus time frame that he interacted with him. 0 Mike Rim ILEA Driver Instructor Described the driver training ILEA provides, and gave opinions on vehicle operation scenarios. He testified that officers are trained that they are responsible for the safety of citizens when operating in emergency conditions, and that they are trained on how to brake under non-ABS braking circumstances. 0 Joshua Herman (Probation Supervisor) He was part of attempting to serve the possessio warning. He h-ad control broadcast the person's tip that he was presently in the area riding a bike. He did not consider this an emergency run, and did not request k9. of marijuana probation violation description because he received a to be Logstics: Officer Jason Cottey was subpoenaed for today, but not called, due to lack of back to Indy. time. He returned Outside of the presence of the jury, the judge told attorneys that, in his opinion, the testimony reference the "2 high ranking females" who went to the property room and inspected the biood viles after the Judge Hawkins preservation order is not something that the jury needs to consider. He said that he did not think that it violated the order, and even if it did, it has no effect in this hearing. The prosecution agreed, but the defense strongly disagreed, and offered to provide case law to further their argument. The judge took the issue under advisement, told the defense to submit any supporting material by tomorrow morning, and the issue would he decided before those witnesses were scheduled to testify on Wednesday. Dav sar Trial Summary Witness Summagjy: Assistant Chief Ron Hicks Responded to the scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard briefly 3 times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. 'Command-er John Conley Responded to the -scene without lights and siren. interacted with Bisard. several times_.. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Explained the policy related to vehicle response types (emergency, non--e1nergency response) Darryl Pierce Responded to the scene without lights and siren. interacted with Bisard several times over the period of several minutes. Did not see signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes be attributed to the air bag deployment. Talked about the pursuit and vehicle operations general orders. Said a response to a felony arrest warrant did not rise to an emergency response level regardless of the position of the officer. The defense began to ask about his meeting with the Chief and Director after leaving the scene, but the prosecution objected, and the question was withdrawn after all parties approached the bench. Daniel. Ryan (K9 officer) Described responding to the scene running with red lights and siren afier being informed by another officer that Bisard was involved in an accident. He said he drove up to 80 MPH on 'the highway and was using his computer. Described the K9 response to a possible felony marijuana warrant as an "urgent" run that was appropriate for an emergency response using red lights and siren. He said that running 10-39 is up to oflicer discretion. He said it is "normal" for ofiicers to operate the in-car computer while driving under emergency conditions, and there are no policies governing that. He said that the K9 unit runs day shift with a minimum stafting of 2 dogs, but that is not always followed. He advised that it was not inappropriate for Bisard to respond to that run under emergency conditions. He advised that, during a phone call two days later, Bisard told him that he was worried about the results of the blood draw showing residual alcohol from his David Bisard Trial Summary consumption of alcohol on the night before the crash. He said that Bisard told him that he did not get drunk, but was drinking. He did not detect signs of intoxication in Bisard on the scene, He advised that Bisard told him during another phone call several months later that he had been drinking Vodka on the night before the crash. 0 Shawn Dent (Regional Director of Methodist Occupational Health) Described the blood draw policy of the agency 0 Sgt. Jeff Paterson (MNE Sgt.) Described responding to the scene, interacting with Bisard, and driving him to Methodist Occupational Health. He did not detect signs of alcohol use. 0 Lt. Benny Diggs Testified he met Bisard at Methodist Occupational, saw the blood draw, then went to roll call with Bisard. They then went to Shapiros for lunch, then he drove him to the garage to get a pool vehicle. He did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. 0 Dr. Saj Alex (Dr. at Methodist Occupational Health) Described his treatment of B-isard. He did not detect any signs of intoxication._ Logistics: Sgt. Horn arrived and learned that the prosecution decided to postpone his testimony until next week-. He then returned to Indy. All other personnel called as witnesses testified and returned to Indy. Dad SrdTia1 Witness Snmmarsg: 0 Barbara Miller (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. 9 Aprit Sohn (Pararnedic). Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. - Dr. Janice Billings (Family doctor of Kurt Weekiy Mary Mills) Described treating Mary and Kurt after the accident I Dr. Bryan Haag (Methodist Hospital surgeon) Described treating Mary Mills in the ER - Dr. Tim Pohlman (Methodist Hospital ER doctor) Described treating Kurt Weekly 0 Kurt Weekly Described his injuries 0 Mary Mills Described her injuries 6 Luisa Montilla (Eric wife) Talked about Wells I George Burk (uninjured Described the events of the crash 0 Officer Thomas Stout (MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and -went to the scene. He checked all victims -and briefly spoke to Bisard, who was distraught. No signs of intoxication. - Officer Brad Millikan (Robbery I Former MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. Bisard was upset, kneeling over Mr. Weekly talking to him. Millikan is a fatal ceitified accident investigator, called for an ET, and asked Bisard for a quick statement. Bisard said he was westbound and looked down, then looked back up and it was too late. Bisard also said his brakes locked up and he had been to the garage for a brake issue earlier in the day. Millikan is a breath test operator also, and be detected no signs of intoxication. David Bisard Trial Summary Logistics: Trial is ahead of schedule baseofi on prosecution witness scheduling. Both Officers were released to return to Indy David Bisard Trial Summary One juror was excluded after he informed the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from Indianapolis stating he had a relative on IMPD and stated that Bisard is guilty and Indy cops drink a lot. He also said that Bisard's wife left himjust before the crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Summary': 0 Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking traffic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. 0 Sheila Beisel (MCSD Communication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications syste1n'(CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. '0 Barbara Belt Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) 0 Jennifer Westfall Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) Lisa Meyer Described witnessing the crash and rendering aid (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren). 0 Samantha Daniels Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) 0 Tamica Franklin Described witnessing the crash -0 Sencbia Perv-inc (IMPD Victim Assistance) Described' her interactions at the scene with the unhurt victim who did advise hearing a siren'. 0 Dana Douing Paramedic (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on the scene 0 Dennis Dorsey EMT (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on scene DaVidBisarcl TrialSumary 0 Todd Ward (Lawrence Fire Dept. EMT) Described treating Eric Wells Logistics: Off. Harman was released and returned to Indy (4 De-Wester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich. Gregory F. Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 5:51 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory I-fire, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Vaierie; Price. Michaef Noiting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Triai Daily Summary Seeattached trial summary Day 5 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich, Gregory Tuesday, October 22, 2013 5:57 PM Sent To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michaei Nailing, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summamdocx See attached trial summary Day 5 David Bisard Trial Sumary Witness Summary: I Jonathan Koers (MND Officer) He was on the original run that Bisard was coming to assist on. He advised that the run was not an emergency run, he did not request k9 backup, and did not see a need for anyone to rush to the scene to assist him. He advised that he does not know k9 protocol, and knows and appreciates that k9 officers must travel long distances. Sgt. Jeff Horn (JNIPD Training Academy) Described IMPD's driver training. Advised that only 30 minutes out of the 40 hour EVOC training recruits receive deals with braking techniques. 0 Commander Karen Arnett Described the driver trainittg curriculum when she supervised the driver training unit, including the time Bisard would have had that training. 0 Sergeant Alan Tuttle Described being at Bisa_rd's house to retrieve his police equipment after the blood test results became known. He overheard Bisard state something to the effect of "there is no way it. could be a He also overheard either Bisard or his wife state that Bisard got up at 0200 the morning of the crash, because he could not sleep, and had a drink, although the type of drink was not specified. 0 Officer Joseph Maxey (MND) Described his radio and laptop communication with Bisard just prior to the crash. 0 Officer Jason Cottey (MND Accident Investigator) Described his role in documenting the crash scene. He advised that he was on another crash investigation about 6 miles away when the Bisard crash occurred. He stated that he finished his original crash investigation, and then went to the Bisard scene. He advised that he traveled to the scene running with his red lights and siren on, and likely traveled above the speed limit. He stated that he did this even "though he knew his response was delayed, and there were others on the scene and no emergency conditions continued to exist there. He did not detect any signs of intoxication on Bisard. a Captain Harold Turner (FACT Commander) Described the functions of -the FACT teams. He stated that he has made over 1,200 DUI arrests and said that he could fail to detect alcohol use if present, and anyone can be fooled. He further talked about types of alcohol and alcohol related smells, and signs of intoxication. Demonstrated a HGN test. David Bisard Trial Sur Log's'tics: Witnesses rel2_1ting to the inspection of the blood in the property room after the Judge Hawkins order will be called, however the line of questioning will not relate to violating the preservation order. . avimsafdilsummary Witness Summam Michelle Johnson (Magda) (Methodist Occupational Health Center Medical Assistant) v' 1/ 1/ Described taking Bisard's blood sample. Followed MOHC protocol, but Lt. Stevenson wanted her to follow the protocol of chain of custody and handling the blood vials. The blood vials on hand were expired, and new vials had to be brought in. She accidently wiped Bisard's right arm with an alcohol swab. She cleaned the arm and her hands, threw out all testing equipment, got new equipment and took blood fi'om his left arm. She handed the vials directly to Lt. Stevens who took possession of thern. She said she did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. The defense attacked her procedures as not following MOHC protocol. 0 Dr. Joyce Carter (Chief Forensic Pathologist for Marion Ca.) She described Brie Wells' fatal wounds a Stan Stevens (Former LPD lieutenant) The defense Was prohibited from getting into the facts of Stevens' separation from LPD in front of the jury. v" v' He was paged as part of FACT Team 6, and went to MOHC to witness the blood draw and take possession. of the. blood. He asked Michelle if she was certified to take the blood, and she replied that she was. He labeled the vials and took possession of them after the blood draw. He left MOHC with the blood vials in his pocket and walked to Hardees for 15-20 minutes before going to the property room. He detected no signs of alcohol consumption by Bisard. . He advised that he did not see Michelle invert the vials 8 times after drawing the blood (as the protocol calls for). He advised that he filled out his paperwork incorrectly when stating that Michelle drew the blood from Bisa_rd's right arm (the arm that the alcohol pad was used on) instead of his left arm. He described the process of checking the vials into the IMPD property 'room. - Rick Winningham (Indianapolis Fleet Services) Is the keeper of records and the title to Bisard's vehicle, and the repair repoit generated for that vehicle Ken Simpson (Mechanic for Indianapolis Fleet Services) David Bsad Trial Sumrna Described doing the preventative maintenance and brake work on B_isard's car on the morning of the crash. He replaced the brake pads on his car, ordered other parts, and released the vehicle back to him in a safe condition. He did not detect intoxication in the hour plus time frame that he interacted with him. Mike Rim Driver Instructor - Described the driver training ILEA provides, and gave opinions on vehicle operation scenarios. He testifred that officers are trained that they are responsible for the safety of citizens when operating in emergency conditions, and that they are trained on how to brake under non-ABS braking circumstances. - Joshua Herman (Probation Supervisor) He was part of attempting to serve the possession of marijuana probation violation warning. He had control broadcast the person's description because he received a tip that he was presently in the area riding a bike. He did not consider this to be an emergency nm, and did not request k9. Logistics Officer Jason Cottey was subpoenaed for today, but not called, due to lack of time. He returned back to Indy. Outside of the presence of the jury, the judge told attorneys that, in his opinion, the testimony reference the "2 high ranking females" who went to the property room and inspected the blood vials after the Judge Hawkins preservation order is not something that the jury needs to consider. He said that he did not think that it violated the order, and even if it did, it has no effect in this hearing. The prosecution agreed, but the defense strongly' disagreed, and offered to provide case law to further their argument. The judge took the issue under advisement, told the defense to submit any supporting material by tomorrow morning, and the issue would he decided before those witnesses were scheduled to testify on Wednesday. Daisriav Witness Summary: 0 Assistant Chief Ron Hicks Responded to the scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard briefly 3 times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Commander John Conley Responded to the scene without lights and siren. lnteracted with Bisard several times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Explained the policy related to vehicle response types (emergency, non-emergency response) Darryl Pierce Responded to the scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard several times over the period of several minutes. Did not see signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Talked about. the pursuit and vehicle operations general orders. Said a response to a_ felony arrest warrant did not rise to an emergency response level regardless of the position of the officer. The defense began to ask about his meeting with the Chief and Director after leaving the scene, but the prosecution objected, and the question was withdrawn after all parties approached the bench. 0 Daniel Ryan (K9 officer) v' Described responding to the scene running with red lights and siren after being informed by another officer that Bisard was involved in an accident. He said he drove up to 80 MPH on the highway and was using his computer. Described the K9 response to a possible felony marijuana warrant as an "urgent" run that was appropriate for an emergency response using red lights and siren. He said that running 1 0-39 is up to officer discretion. He said it is "normal" for officers to operate the in-car computer while driving under emergency conditions, and there are no policies governing that. He said that the K9 unit runs day shift with a minimum staffing of 2 dogs, but that is not always followed. He advised that it was not inappropriate for Bisard to respond to that run under emergency conditions. He advised that, during a phone call two days later, Bisard told him that he was worried about the results of the blood draw showing residual alcohol from his consumption of alcohol on the night before the crash. He said that Bisard told him that he did not get drunk, but was 'x Devi Filua -- He did not detect signs of intoxication in Bisard on the scene. He advised that Bisard told him during another phone call severa had been drinking vodka on the night before the crash. 1 months later that he 0 Shawn Dent (Regional Director of Methodist Occupational Health) Described the blood draw policy of the agency 9 Sgt-. Jeff Paterson (MNE Sgt.) Described responding to the scene, interacting with Bisard, and driving him to Methodist Occupational Health. He did not detect signs of alcohol use. 0 Lt. Benny Diggs Testified he met Bisard at Methodist Occupational, saw the blood draw, then went to roll call with Bisard. They then went' to Shapiros for lunch, then he drove him to the garage to get a pool vehicle. He did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. 0 Dr. Saj Alex (Dr. at Methodist Occupational Health) Described his treatment of Bisard. He did not detect any signs of intoxication. Logistics: Sgt. Horn arrived and learned that the prosecution decided to postpone his testimony until next week. He then returned to Indy. All other personnel called as witnesses testified and returned to Indy. Data "(I)ay 2) DaViBisdI'a1Sa Witness Summary; 0 Barbara Miller (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. April Sohn (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. -I Dr. Janice Billings (Family doctor of Kurt Weekly Mary Mills) Described treating Mary and Kurt after the accident 0 Dr. Bryan Haag (Methodist Hospital surgeon) Described treating Mary Mills in the ER 0 Dr. Tim Pohlman (Methodist Hospital ER doctor) Described treating Kurt Weekly 4- Kurt Weekly Described his injuries I Mary Mills Described her injuries *0 Luisa Montilla (Eric Well's Wife) Talked about Wells a George Burk (uninjured Described the events of the crash 0 Officer Thomas Stout (MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. He checked all victims and briefly spoke to Bisard, who was distraught. No signs of intoxication. an Officer Brad Millikan (Robbery I Former MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. Bisard was upset, kneeling over Mr. Weekly talking to him. Millikan is a fatal certified accident- investigator, called for an ET, and asked Bisard for a quick statement. Bisard said he was Westbound and looked down, then looked back up and it was too late. Bisard also said his brakes locked up and he had been to the garage for a brake issue earlier in the day. Millikan is a breath test operator also, and he detected no signs of intoxication. Vic' 131" rial Sm'? -- Logistics: Trial is ahead of schedule based on prosecution witness scheduling. Both oflicers were released to return to Indy (5)13 Did Bisard Trial Summary One juror was excluded after he informed the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from Indianapolis stating -he had a relative on IMPD and stated that Bisard is guilty and Indy cops drinic a lot-. He also said that Bisard's wife left him just before the crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Sumniarv: 9 Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking traffic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. I Sheila Beisel (MCSI) C-ominunication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications system (CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. I Barbara Belt Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) Jennifer Westfali Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did -observe lights I siren) 0 Lisa Meyer . Described witnessing the crash and rendering aid ('excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) 0 Samantha Daniels Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) 0 Tamica Franklin Described witnessing the crash 0 Senobia Pervine (IMPD Victim Assistance) Described her interactions at the scene with the unhurt victim who did advise hearing a siren. 0- Dana Douiizg Paramedic (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on the scene I Dennis Dorsey'EMT (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Milis on scene - Todd Ward (Lawrence Fire Dept. EMT) Described treating Eric Wells Dvid Bisa -1 Logistics: Off. Harman was released and returned to Indy Dewester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Tuesday, October :22, 2013 6:00 PM To: Bieberich, -Gregory P. Subject: Trial Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summary.docx David 311 Witness Summarjg 0 Jonathan Koers (MND Officer) He was on the original run that Bisard was coming to assist on. He advised that the run was not an emergency run, he did not request k9 backup, and did not see a need for anyone to rush to the scene to assist him-. He advised that he does not know k9 protocol, and knows and appreciates that k9 officers must travel long distances. 0 Sgt. Jeff Horn (IMPD Training Academy) Described IMPD's driver training. Advised that only 30 minutes out of the 40 hour EVOC training recruits receive deals with braking techniques. 0 Commander Karen Arnett Described the driver training curriculum when she supervised the driver training unit, including the time Bis ard would have had that training. 0 Sergeant Alan Tattle Described being at Bisard's house to retrieve his police equipment after the blood test results became known. He overheard Bisard state something to the effect of "there is no way it could be a He also overheard either Bisard or his wife state that Bisard got up at 0200 the morning of the crash, because he could not sleep, and had a drink, although the type of drink was not specified. a Officer Joseph Maxey (MND) Described his radio and laptop communication with Bisard just prior to the crash. 0 Officer Jason Cottey (MND Accident Investigator') Described his role in "documenting the crash scene. He advised that he was on another crash investigation about 6 miles away when the Bisard crash occurred. He stated that he finished his original crash investigation, and then went to the Bisard scene. He advised that he traveled to the scene running with his red lights and siren on, and likely traveled above the speed limit. He stated that he did this even though he knew his response was delayed, and there were others on the scene and no emergency conditions continued to exist there. He did not detect any signs of intoxication on Bisard. 0 Captain Harold Turner (FACT Commander) Described the functions of the FACT teams. He stated that he has made over 1,200 DUI arrests and said that he could fail to detect alcohol use if present, and anyone can be. fooled. He further talked about types of alcohol and alcohol related smells, and signs of intoxication. Deznonstrated a HGN test. aid Bisard Ta1Sum1'nry Logistics: Witnesses relating to the inspection of the blood in the property room after the Judge Hawkins order will be called, however the line of questioning will not relate to violating the preservation order. aVidBi3a1'dTFi315mmarY Witness 0 Michelle Johnson (Magda) (Methodist Occupational Health Center Medical Assistant) v' v' Described taking Bisard's blood sample. Followed MOHC protocol, but Lt. "Stevenson wanted her to follow the protocol of chain of custody and handling the blood vials. The blood vials on hand were expired, and new vials had to be brought in. She accidently wiped Bisard's right arm with an alcohol swab. She cleaned the arm and her hands, threw out all testing equipment, got new equipment and took blood from his left arm. She handed the vials directly to Lt. Stevens who took possession of them. She said she did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. The defense attacked her procedures as not following MOHC protocol. 0 Dr. Joyce Carter (Chief Forensic Pathologist for Marion Co.) She described Eric Wells' fatal wounds Stan Stevens (Former LPD lieutenant) The defense was prohibited getting into the facts of Stevens' separation from LPD in front of the jury. at' v' He was paged as part of FACT Team 6, and went to MOI-IC to witness the blood draw and take possession of the blood. He asked Michelle if she was certified to take the blood, and she replied that she was. He labeled the vials and took possession of them after the blood draw. He lefi MOI-IC with the blood vials in his pocket and walked to Hardees for 15-20 minutes before going to the property room. He detected no signs of alcohol consumption by Bisard. He advised that he did not see Michelle invert the vials 8 times afier drawing the blood (as the protocol calls for). He advised that he filled out his paperwork incorrectly when stating that Michelle drew the blood from Bisard's right arm (the arm that the alcohol pad was used on) instead of his left arm. He described the process of checking the vials into the IMPD property room. - Rick Winningham (Indianapolis Fleet Services) Is the keeper of records and introduced the title to Bisard's vehicle, and the repair report generated for that vehicle 0 Ken Simpson (Mechanic for Indianapolis Fleet Services) pp avid Bsard Tria Surnmar Described doing the preventative maintenance and brake work on Bisard's car on the morning of the crash. He replaced the brake pads on his car, ordered other parts, and released the vehicle back to him in a safe condition. He did not detect intoxication in the hour plus time frame that he. interacted with him. 0 Mike Rim ILEA Driver Instructor Described the driver training ILEA provides, and gave opinions on vehicle operation scenarios. He. testified that officers are trained that they are responsible for the safety of citizens when operating in emergency conditions, and that they are trained on how to brake under non-ABS braking circumstances. 0 Joshua Herman (Probation Supervisor) He was part of attempting to serve the possession of marijuana probation violation warning. He had control broadcast the person's description because he received a tip that he was presently in the area riding a bike. He did not consider this to be an emergency run, and did not request 1:9. Log' tics: Officer Jason Cottey was subpoenaed for today, but not called, due to lack of time. He returned back to lady. I Outside of the presence of the jury, the judge told attorneys that, in his opinion, the testimony reference the "2 high ranking females" who went to the property room and inspected the blood vials after the Judge Hawkins preservation order is not something that the jury needs to consider. He said that he did not think that it violated the order, and even it did, it has no effect in this hearing. The prosecution agreed, but the defense strongly disagreed, and offered to provide case law to further their arguxnent. The judge took the issue under advisement, told the defense to submit any supporting material by tomorrow morning, and the issue would he decided before those witnesses were scheduled to testify on Wednesday. Dr? iSa1'T1"i1 Smart Witness Summing Assistant Chief Ron Hicks Responded to the scene without lights and siren. interacted with Bisard briefly 3 times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Commander John Conley Responded to the scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard several times. Did not observe signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Explained the; policy related to vehicle response types (emergency, non-emergency response) Darryl Pierce Responded to the scene without lights and siren. Interacted with Bisard several times over the period of several minutes. Did not see signs of intoxication. Described Bisard as having red eyes he attributed to the air bag deployment. Talked about the pursuit and vehicle operations general orders. Said a response to a felony arrest warrant did not rise to an emergency response level regardless of the position of the officer. The defense began to ask about his meeting with the Chief and Director after leaving the scene, but the prosecution objected, and the question was withdrawn after all parties approached the bench. Daniel Ryan (K9 officer) Described responding to the scene running with red lights and siren after being informed by another officer that Bisard was involved in an accident. He said he drove up to 80 MPH on the highway and was using his computer. Described the K9 response to a possible felony marijuana warrant as an "urgent" run that was appropriate for an emergency response using red lights and sire_n. He said that running 10-39 is up to ofiioer discretion. He said it is "normal" for officers to operate the in~car computer while driving under emergency conditions, and there are no policies governing that. He said that the K9 unit runs day shifi with a minimum stafiing of 2 dogs, but that is not always followed. He advised that it was not inappropriate for Bisard to respond to that run under emergency conditions. He advised that, during a phone call two days later, Bisard told him that he was worried about the results of the blood draw showing residual alcohol from his consumption of alcohol on the night before the crash. He said that Bisard told him that he did not get drunk, but was drinking. David Biard rial Summary pp . v' He did not detect signs of intoxication in Bisard on the scene. He advised that Bisard told him during another phone call several months later that he had been drinking vodka on the night before the crash. Shawn Dent (Regional Director of Methodist Occupational Health) Described the blood draw policy of the agency Sgt. Jeff Paterson (MNE Sgt.) Described responding to the scene, interacting with Bisard, and driving him to Methodist Occupational Health. He did not detect signs of alcohol use. Lt. Benny Diggs Testified he met Bisard at Methodist Occupational, saw the blood draw, then went to roll call with Bisard. They then went to Shapiros for lunch, then he drove him to the garage to get a pool vehicle. He did not detect signs of alcohol use by Bisard. Dr. Saj Alex (Dr. at Methodist Occupational Health) Described his treatment of Bisard. He did not detect any signs of intoxication. Logistics: Sgt..Horn'arrived and learned that the prosecution decided to postpone his testimony until next week. He then returned to Indy. All other personnel called as witnesses testified and returned to Indy. Date: David Bisard Trial Summy Witness Surnmarv: 0 Barbara Miller (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. 0 April Sohn (Paramedic) Described treating Bisard on the scene. Observed no signs of intoxication. a Dr. Janice Billings (Family doctor of Kurt Weekly Mary Mills) Described treating Mary and Kurt after the accident 0 Dr. Bryan Haag (Methodist Hospital surgeon) Described treating Mary Mills in the ER 0 Dr. Tim Pohlman (Methodist Hospital ER doctor) Described treating Kurt Weekly 0 Kurt Weekly Described his injuries a Mary Mills Described her injuries 0 Luisa Montilia (Eric WeIl's wife) Talked about Wells 0 George Burk (uninjured Described the events of the crash 0 Officer Thomas Stout (MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and Went to the scene. He checked all victims and briefly spoke to Bisard, who was distraught. No signs of intoxication. 0 Officer Brad Millikan (Robbery I Former MND) Heard Bisard broadcast the crash on the radio and went to the scene. Bisard was upset, kneeling over Mr. Weekly talking to him. Millikan is a fatal certified accident investigator, called for an ET, and asked Bisard for a quick statement. Bisard said he was westbound and looked down, then looked back up and it was too late. Bisard also said his brakes locked up" and he had been to the garage for a brake issue earlier in the day. Millikan is a breath test operator also, and he detected no signs of intoxication. David Bisard Ta} Sua Logistics: Trial is ahead of schedule based on prosecution witness scheduling. Both officers were released to return to Indy 2: .1 3' '33- . 2 .. 577 '5 "mm - One juror was excluded after he informed the judge that he overheard a conversation at a business meeting on Monday (after being seated as a juror) involving a business person from Indianapolis stating he had a relative on IMPD and stated that Bisard is guilty and Indy cops drink a lot. He also said that Bisard's wife left him just before the' crash, and Bisard has been arrested for DUI since this incident. An alternate juror was put in his place. Witness Summarv: 0 Officer Harman (MND) He described the run he was on with Bisard that morning, and his involvement in blocking trafic at the crash scene. He did not see Bisard. Sheila Beisel (MCSD Communication employee) She described the CAD and recording communications system (CAD and recordings were entered as evidence. Barbara Belt" . Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights siren) Jennifer Westfail Described witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) Lisa Meyer Described witnessing the crash and rendering aid (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) Samantha Daniels Described" witnessing the crash (excessive speed and did observe lights I siren) Tamica Franklin Described witnessing the crash Senobia Pervine Victim Assistance) Described her interactions at the scene with the unhurt victim who did advise hearing a siren. Dana Douing Paramedic (Medic 24) Described treating Ms. Mills on the scene Dennis Dorsey EMT (Medic 24-) Described treating Ms. Mills on scene Todd Ward (Lawrence. Fire Dept. EMT) . Described treating Eric Wells DaVidBiadiaI5ummr Logistics: Off. Harman was released and returned 'to Indy Dewester, Samantha E. From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: . Wednesday, October 23, 2013 9:35 AM To: 'Pasel, Jeremy Subject: FW: Triai Daily Summary Attachments: Bis-ard Trial Summaryxiocx ii-rem: Sent: Monday,_ October. 21, 2013 6:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached triai summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E, Turner, Harold From: Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:29 PM To: Hirschauer, Tom Subject: Fwd: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summarydocx; ATT5658436.htm I found one. I have not read this one, but it is an example of what has been sent daily since trial began. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded meosage: From: "Price, Michael Date: October 21, 2013 at 7:05:11 PM EDT To:' "Turner, Harold" "Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary .. -.-Fromigieberioh, Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 06:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 6:50 PM To: Foley, Edward Subject: Fw: Trial Daiiy Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summarydocx From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 06:22 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Tria! Daily Summary - See attached trfai summary Day 2 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 6:52 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Sumrnaryxlocx From: Bieberich, Gregory Pl. Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2613 -06:22 PM . To: Bieberich, Gregory Hlte, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 2 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 6:58 PM To: Snitko, Geraldine A. Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Surnmary.docx Bieberlch, Gregory Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 06:22 PM To: Bieberfch, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 2 Dewester, Samantha E. Price, Michael A From: Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 9:05 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Dairy Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summary.docx -um vu--H-1 . Gregory P. Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lc-rah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michae! Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary - See attached tria} summary Day 3 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October '18, 2013 9:05 PM To: Foley, Edward Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: -Bisard Trial Summarydocx From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 09:04 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary l-From: Gregory P. Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bleberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial sum mary Day 3 Dewester, Samantha E, From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 9:06 PM To: Snitko, Geraldine A. Subject: Fw: Trial Dally Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summaryxiocx From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 09:04 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary 'gum: Bieberlch, Gregory P. Sent: Frlday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory -Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 3 -Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 9:08 PM To: Foiey, Edward Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summary.docx From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary - See attached triai summary Day 3 Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Noiting, Ted W. Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October '18, 2013 9:08 PM To: Sniiko, Geraldine A. Subject: Fw. Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summaryoocx From: Bieberich, Gregory -- Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory I-lite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Ted W. Subject: RE: Trlal Dally Summary See attached trial summary Day 3 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 9:09 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summaryxiocx From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 06:25 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 3 Dewester, Samantha E. Price, Michael A From: Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 7:08 PM To: Snitko, Geraldine A. Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: BIsard.Trial Summaryxiocx Gregory F. Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 06:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached triai summary Day 4 Michael Nolting, Ted W. Dewester, Samantha From: Price, MichaelA Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 7:06 PM To: Foley, Edward Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summary.do.cx From: Bieherich, Gregory P. Sent-: Monday, October 21, 2013 06:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michaei Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Triai Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price. Michael A Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 7:05 PM To: Turner, Harold; Robinson, David Subject: Fw: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summarydoox From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 06:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory I-lite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See. attached trial summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Price, Michael A Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 6:22 PM To: Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Netting, Ted Cunningham, Valerie Subject: Fw: Attachments: Bisard Trial Summamdocx From: Greg Bieberich Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 06:15 PM To: Price, Michael A Subject: Dewester, Samantha E. rom: Noiting, Ted W. Sent: - Thursday, October 17, 2013 9:28 AM To: Garrison. Bekh A. Subject: FW: Trial Daily Summary Attach merits: Bisard Tria! Summanadocx Nothing saiacious on day 1 From: Bleberich, Gregory P. Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2013 6:30 PM To: Hite, Richard; Lorah, wiliiam; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Cc: Bleberich, Gregory P. Subject: Triai Daily Summary See attached trial summary Dawester, Samantha E. From: Noiting, Ted W. - Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 10:23 AM To: Garrison, Beth A. Subject: FW: Trial Daily/.St1mmary' Attachments: Bisard. Trial Summaryxjocx From: pf Sent: Thursday, October 2013 6:23 PM To: Bieberfch, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 2 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Nolting, Ted W. Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 9:09 AM To: Garrison, Beth A. . Subject: FW: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summaryxdoox . FYI. Sent: Monday, October 21, 2013 6:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, Wiiliam; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached triai summary Day 4 De-Wester, Samantha E. From: Nolting, Ted W. Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 6:31 PM To: Garrison, Beth A. Subject: Fwd: Attachments: Bisard Trial Summary.docx Sem'ji'om my Verizon Wirefess 4 LTE DROID Original Message Subject: Fw: From: "Price, Michael To: "Hits, Richard" William" Ted ,qov>, "Cunningham, Valerie" gov> CC: From: Greg Bieberich Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 06:15 PM To: Price', Michael A Subject: Dewester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, William Sent: Wednesday, October 23, 2013 11:49 AM To: Dewester, Samantha E. Subject: FW: Trial Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summary.do-ox Bill Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indian?ipofis Metropolitan Police Department Department of Public Safety 50 North Alabama E310 Indianapo1is,I.n. 462 04 3.17-321358-4 office Police-Fire-Homeland Security--Animal Care and From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2013 6:30 PM To: Hire, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michael Netting, Ted W. Cc: Biebefich, Gregory F. Subject: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial sum mary De-Wester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, William Sent: Wednesday, October 23, 2013 1 1:49 AM To: Dewester, Samantha E. Subject: FW: Trial Daiiy Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summaryadocx Biil Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Departlnent Department of Public Safety 50 North Alabama St E310 IndianapoI1's,In. 46204 317-327-3534 oflice Police-Fire-Homefand Security-Animal Care and Sent: Thursday, October 17, 2013 6:23 PM Tn: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerie; Price, Michae! Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Triai Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 2 Dewester, Samantha From: Lorah, Wiliiam Sent: Wednesday, October 23, .2013 11:49 AM To: Dewester, Samantha E. Subject: FW: Triai Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Trial Summarydocx Bifl Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department Department of Public Safety 50 North Alabama St E310 Indianapo1is,In, 46204 317-327-3584 office Police-Fire-Homeianci Security-Animal Care and From: Bieberich, Gregory P. Sent: Friday, October 18, 2013 6:26 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory P. Hite, Richard; Lorah, Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary imam; Cunningham, Vaierie; Price, Michael Noiting, Ted W. See attached triai summary Day 3 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Lorah. William Sent: Wednesday, October 23, 2013 11:51 AM To - Dewester, Samantha E. Subject: FW: Triai Daily Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai 'Summary.docx Bill Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department" of Public Safety 50 North Alabama St E310 IndianapoIjs,In. 46204 317-327-3584 affice williamlorah i ov Police-Fire-Homefand Secu.rity--Animal Care and Sent: Monday, 'October 21, 2013 6:47 PM To: Bieberich, Gregory Hite, Richard; Lorah, Wlliiarmcunningham, Valerie; Price, Michaei Nolting, Ted W. Subject: RE: Triai Daily Summary - See attached trial summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, Wiltiam Sent: Wednesday, October 23, 2013 11:52 AM To: Dewester, Samantha E. Subject: FW: Attachments: Bisard Trial Summaryoocx Got this on from Price because Bieberich get out look to work so he sent it to Price to forward. Bifl Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department Department of Public Safety 50 North Alabama St E310 Indianapo3js,Ir'1. 46204 317-327-3584 office Police-Fire-Homeiand Security-Animal Care and . .. .. -. Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 6:22 PM To: Hite, Richard; Lorah, William; Nolting, Ted W. Cunningham, Valerie Subject: Fw: From: Greg Bieberich Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 06:15 PM To: Price, Michael A Subject: Dewester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, William Sent: Wednesday. October 23, 2013 11:53 AM To:' Dewester, Samantha E. Su bject: FW: Trial Daily Summary Day 5 that came in this morning from Cyber Space. This is the one that Price forwarded last night because Outlook wouldn't work Bil} Lorah Deputy Chief Criminal Investigations Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department Department of Public Safety 50 North Alabama St E310 Ind'ianapolis,In. 46204 317-327-3534 office william.1orah@indy.gov Police-Fire-Homeland Security-Animal Care and .. . . . Sent: Wednesday, October 23, 2013 9:33 AM To: Bieberlch, Gregory Hire, Richard; Lorah, William; Cunningham, Valerle; Price, Michael Ted W. Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 5 Dewester, Samantha E. . From: Lorah, Wimam "Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 11:31 PM To: Washington, Valerie R. Subject: Fwd: Fw: Attachments: Bisard Trial Summarydocx; ATT5684345.htm Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Lo1'a.h, William" Date: October 22, 2013. at 8:34:57 PM EDT To: "Robinson, Denise Subject: Fwd: Fw: Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Price, Michael Date: October 22, 2013 at 6:21 :53 PM EDT To: "Hite, Richard" "Lorah, "William" "Noiting, Ted "Cunningham, Valerie" Subject: Fw: From: Greg Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 06:15 PM To: Price, Michael A Subject: De-waster, Samantha E. From: Lorah, Wiliiam Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 11:31 PM To: Washington, Vaierie R. Su bject: Fwd: Tn'_aI Daiiy Summary Attachments: Bisard Tria! Summarydoox; ATT56842?3.htm Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Lorah, Wiiliam" Date: October 22, 2013 at 8:34:24 PM EDT To: "Robinson, Denise Subject: Fwd: Trial Daily Summary Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Bieberich, Gregory Date: October 21, 2013 at 6:47:21 PM EDT To: "Bieb'erich, Gregory "I-iite, Richard" "Lorah, William" "Cunningham, Valerie" "Price, Michael "hiolting, Ted S.ubJect: RE: Trial Daily Summary See attached trial summary Day 4 Dewester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, Wiiliam - Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:34 PM To: Robinson, Denise A. Subject: - Fwd: Trial Daiiy Summary Attachments: Bisard Triai Summary.docx; ATT5659255.htm Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Bieberich, Gregory Date: October 21, 2013 at 6:47:21. PM EDT To: "Bieberich, Gregory "Hire, Richard" "Lorah, William" "Cunningham, Valerie" "Price, Michael "Nofting, Ted Subject: RE: Trial Daily Summary - See attached trial summary Day 4 De-Wester, Samantha E. From: Lorah, William Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 8:35 PM To: Robinson, Denise A. - Subject: Fwd: Fw: Attachments: Bisard Trial Summary.docx; ATT5659333.htm Sent from my iPhonc Begin forwarded message: From: "Price, Michael Date: October 22, 2013 at 6:21:53 PM EDT T0: "Hits, Richard" "Lorah, William" "Nolting, Ted "Cunningham, Valerie" Subject: FW: From: Greg Bieberich Sent: Tuesday, October 22, 2013 06:15 PM "To: Price, Michael A Subject: Date Time 10/16/2013 22:30:32 GMT 10/16/2013 22:30:32 GMT 10/16/2013 22:30:32 GMT 10/16/2013 22:30:32 GMT 10/16/2013 22:30:32 10/16/2013 22:30:32 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/17/2013 22:22:50 GMT 10/13/2013 22:25:1 GMT 10/13/2013 22:26:1 GMT 10/13/2013 22:26:1 GMT 10/13/2013 22:26:1 GMT 10/13/2013 22:26:1 GMT 10/13/2013 22:26:1 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/21/2013 22:47:33 GMT 10/23/2013 . 10/23/2013 13:32:41 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:41 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:41 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:41 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:41 10/23/2013 13:32:41 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:42 GMT 10/23/2013 13:32:43 GMT 10/23/2013 0:29:14 GMT 10/17/2013 11:40:4 GMT Recipient-Address Richard.Hite@indy.gov Ted.N0Iting@indy.g0v VaIerie.Cunningham@indy.g0V Richard.Hite@indy.g0v Ted.NoIting@indy.g0v WiIliam.L0rah@indy.g0v Michael.Price@indy.gov Richard.Hite@indy.gov Greg0ry.Bieberich@indy.g0v Richard.Hite@indy.gov Richard.Hite@indy.g0v Valerie.Cunningham@indy.gov Richard.Hite@indy.gov Ted.NoIting@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Wi.Iliam.Lorah@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@Endy.g0v T0m.Hirschauer@indy.g0v Geraldine.Snitko@indy.g0v 0rigination--Time 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-16 22:30:32 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-17 22:22:50 GMT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 GMT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 GMT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 GMT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 MT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 GMT 2013-10-18 22:26:1 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 2013-10-21 22:47:33 GMT 13:35:15 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 7 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:40 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:42 GMT 2013-10-23 13:32:43 GMT 2013-10-23 0:29:13 GMT 2013-10-17 11:40:4 GMT 10/17/2013 11:40:4 GMT 10/17/2013 11:40:5 GMT 10/17/2013 12:15:10 GMT 10/19/2013 1:4:53 GMT 10/19/2013 1:4:54 GMT 10/19/2013 15:19 GMT 10/19/2013 1:13:24 GMT 10/19/2013 1:7:52 GMT 10/19/2013 1:3:14 GMT 10/19/2013 1:3:35 GMT 10/19/2013 1:3:35 GMT 10/21/2013 23:5:12 GMT 10/21/2013 23:5:13 GMT 10/21/2013 23:5:37 GMT 10/21/2013 2327139 GMT 10/22/2013 22:21:54 GMT 10/22/2013 22:21:54 GMT 10/22/2013 22:21:54 GMT 10/22/2013 22:21:54 GMT 10/22/2013 22:21:55 GMT 10/17/2013 13:27:42 GMT 10/13/2013 14:23:10 GMT 10/22/2013 13:9:20 GMT 10/22/2013 22:31:33 GMT 10/23/2013 15:52:19 GMT 10/23/2013 15:43:55 GMT 10/23/2013 15:49:5 GMT 10/23/2013 15:49:14 GMT 10/23/2013 15:50:43 GMT 10/23/2013 15:53:15 GMT 10/23/2013 10/23/2013 3:31:13 GMT 10/23/2013 10/23/2013 3:30:55 GMT Harold.Turner@indy.gov David.R0bins0n@indy.g0v David.R0bins0n@indy.g0v GeraIdine.Snitk0@.indy.g0v Edwa rd .F0ley@indy.gov David.Robin5on@indy.g0v Ha roId.Turne r@indy.gov GeraIdirie.Snitko@indy.gov Richard.Hite@indy.gov VaIerie.Cunningham@indy.gov Beth.Garris0n@indy.gov Beth.Garris0n@indy.g0v Sa Samantha.DeWester2@indy.gov Sarnantha.DeWester2@indy.g0v Sam-a ntha.DeWester2@indy.gov Samantha.DeWe5ter2@indy.gov Samantha.DeWester2@indy.gov 2013-10-17 11:40:4 GMT 2013-10-17 11:40:4 GMT 2013-10-17 12:14:54 GMT 2013-10-19 1:4:53 GMT 2013-10-19 1:4:53 GMT 2013-10-19 1:5:19 GMT 2013-10-19 1:6:24 GMT 2013-10-19 1:7:52 GMT 2013-10-19 1:53:14 GMT 2013-10-19 1:53:34 GMT 2013-10-19 1:8:34 GMT 2013-10-21 23:5:12 GMT 2013-10-21 23:5:12 GMT 2013-10-21 23:53? GMT 2013-10-21 23:7:38 GMT 2013-10-22 22:.21:53 GMT 2013-10-22 22:21:53 GMT 2013-10-22 22:21:53 GMT 2013-10-22 22:21:53 GMT 2013-10-22 22:21:53 GMT 2013-10-17 13:27:42 GMT 2013-10-18 14:23:10 GMT 2013-10-22 13:9:20 GMT 2013-10-22 22:31:32 GMT 2013-10-23 15:52:19 GMT 2013-10-23 15:43:55 GMT 2013-10-23 15:49:5 GMT 2013-10-23 15:49:13 GMT 2013-10-23 15:50:43 GMT 2013-10-23 15:53:15 GMT 2013;-10-23 0:35:-:0 GMT 2013-10-23 3:31:13 GMT 2013-10-23 0:34:23 GMT 2013-10-23 3:30:54 GMT Message-Subject Trial Daily Summary Triai Daily Summary Triai Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: FW: Triajl 'D'ail_y . RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: RE: Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daiiy Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial 'Daily Summary Trial' Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Triai Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daiiy Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Daily Summary Trial Summary Fwd: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary Sender>>-Add ress Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@incly.gov Gregory.Bie berich@indy.gov Greg0ry.Biaberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bi_e berich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov . Gregory.Bieberich@incly.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@indy.g0v regory.Bie be rich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@incly.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@.incly.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Gregory.Bieberich@indy.gov Gregory.Bieberich@indy.goy Michael.Price@indy.gov FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Trial Daily Summary- Fw: Trial Daily Summary Fw: Fw: Fw: Fw: FW: FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary Fwd: FW: . FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary FW: Trial Daily Summary Fw: -- Fwd: Fw: Fwd; Trial Daily Summary' Fwd: Trial Daily Summary lViichael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michael.Price@indy.gov Michaei.Price@indy.g0V Michael.Price@indy.gov Ted.Nolting@indy.gav Ted.N0lting@indy.gov Ted.Nolting@indy.gov William.Lorah@indy.gov William.Lorah@indy.gov William.Lprah@indy.gov wiIliarn.Lorah@indy.gov