COMMONWEALTH OF  

COUNTY OF: YORK . vs,

MansIahaI Dnsvim Number. 19.3-04 DEFENDANT: (NAME and ADDRESS).

MDJ Name: Han, JEFFREY s. JOY JEFFREY SCOTT JOV

Adana" 165 FAIRVIEW CT. 

NEW DOM pA1734g 'FIrsINams MMdleNama LISINIM Gun
13 4TH ST,
TaIaphonu, 717-227-0658 NEW FREEDOM, PA 17349
New EXTRADITION conE TYPE
Jelmy run El 5mm, mu El c-mamsahm sIaI-r mama
Melony Ltd. McIon Pam madman Dakml MIsdsmaannI Np Emma-n
mm sme; I: ILMIsdzmexnar smasmm Panama
mm us Ext FrMImamunol alumna" Delavm.
DEFENDANY IDENYIFICATION INFORMATION
Docka| Number one OTN/leeScan Numhar Number sm: Renuost Lab Sen/Ices?
I I H7-2365181 Elvss [Zinc
GENDER DOB 03/18/65 I POE Add'l nos IGu~Dalandanl{s) 
W8 Name>> uruua Name Las! Nan-I: as"
Female JEFF JOY
RACE IE wmta Aslan Elm Name American El Unknown
ETHNICITY Hlspamn I2 Non urspam 
HAIR COLOR GRV(fimy) RED (IurI/Aubm) El sImsahrIy) arm) PLkU'mplz) unorarm)
El fllelack) one (cram) (mm) (Uhk. [Bum] Cl mm (cum mount)
um IBImds/ 
EYE COLOR swam>>) aw (Elna) l] mo (Brown) GRN (arm-I 
El m1 MAR (Maroon) mum) El (IIuInuwn)
Drlver Lie-nae sIan License Numpar Expires: 03/19/19 WEIGHV (lbs)
DNA ves No DNA chaIIon
FBI Numhpr MNU Number Fl, HEIGHT In.
Denndam FIngorprIuI 
DEFENDANY VEHICLE INFORMATION
Flawil sraIa HazmaI ngluranoh suck-rIMM/WI I comm-Ivan. Ind. Schaoleh. lam. NcIc Vah. Cam; My
'3 same

VIN Vezr Make Model stIa Color 3558'-

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sam'mm:Usnfauherszw'mzumw'm'

DANIEL J. DYE DAG
WquI/myvm

 
   

I. TPR JONATHAN COLARUSSC 00626219l10273
u. a we a 
loe Perms IvaniaS [a Police I fAFsEfMoo
mm mm . I 

do hereby sIaIe: (check approprIaIe box)
1. I2 I accuse [he above named devehdam who Iiuas Ihe address as! mm above
I accuse Ihe devehdanI whose name Is unknown In me bu( who Is described as 

I accuse [ha delsndam whose name and popular designalion or nickname is unknown Ia me and whom I have Iherevare desIgnaIed
as John Doe or Jane Doe.

 

wiIh violating [he penal laws (7(th Commonweauh DI al: 410 25 WATER STREET APTV it 4 GLEN ROCK
awn-mm,
)n YORK County 57 on or abuut 03/04/15 BETWEEN 16004700 HRS,
mm. 

AOPC 412A-Rev.1zl14 Page 1 of 1

 

fl POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

 

 

 

 

 

 

Docket Numhar: Date Filed: OTNlleeScan Number Complaint/Incident Number
I H7>>2368t91
First: Middle: Last
"we JEFFREY scoTT JOY

 

 

 

The acts committed by the accused are described below with each Act ol Assembly or statute allegedly violated, it

ap ropriate. When there is more than one oliense, each ottense should be numbered chronologically.
ts-t <i

 

3333' POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Filed: DTNIlecScan Number Complaint/Incident Number
I I H7-2359191
First: Middle: Last'

Name JEFFREY sco'rr 7 JOY

 

 

 

 

 

 

The acts committed by the accused are described below with each Act of Assembly or statute allegedly violated, if
appropriate. When there is more than one offense, each offense should be numbered chronologically.

(set loan mm "may oi the ram maria-m to :avts- In: <s consent,

 

 

 

 

AOPC 412A -- Rav.12/14 Page 1 

 

i492}. i

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

 

 

 

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Filed: OTNiLiveScan Number Complaintlincident Number
I H7-2369191
First: Middle: Last:
Defendant Name JEFFREY scorr JOY

 

 

 

2. I ask that a warrant of arrest or a summons be issued and that the defendant be required to answer the

charges I have made.

3. verify that the facts set forth in this complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge or
information and belief. This verification is made subject to the penalties of Section 4904 of the Crimes
Code (18 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.

4. This complaint consists of the preceding page(s) numbered 1_ through 4

The acts committed by the accused, as listed and hereafter, were against the peace and dignity of the
Commonwealth of and were contrary to the Act(s) of the Assembly, or in violation of the statutes

cited.

(Before a warrant of arrest can be issued, an affidavit of probable cau must be completed, sworn to
before the issuing authority, and attached.)

mg? in) 15?

AND NOW, on this date,

9" 2.5

  

If
Ema rs c-fAf?anl)

A.

..

I certify that the complaint has been properly

Q2.reeP:11

completed and verified. An affidavit of plows: must be completed before a warrant can be issued.

12-3-0?

{I'dagtsiertai District Court Punt-a)

Useran My)

Search rd may gram 9. L.
Tu:le 



rmqu



 



-

?If?



 

?I?Hmnnumi?

 

AOPC 412A Rev. 12114

Page of i

 

 

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Filed: OTNILivaScan Number: Complaint/Incident Number
I H772369191

First: Middle: Last:

Defendant Namc: Jew Sm" Joe

 

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE

Your affiant is a State Trooper currently assigned to the Criminal Investigation Unit,
Troop York Station. I have been a member of the State Police since December of
2005 and have been in the Criminal Investigation Unit since October of 2011. In that time I have
conducted numerous sexual assault investigations that have resulted in successful prosecution.
Additionally, I have investigated major and complex incidents including homicides. police involved
shootings, other violent crimes such as attempted homicides and robberies, and financial crimes. 1
have also received extensive training in interviewing techniques.

On 03/04/15 lwas assi ned to investi ate an incident involving an adult female victim identified in
this document asH who reported she was sexually assaulted the defendant,

York Count Ma at District Judge Jeffrey Scott JOY. At the time of this incident, resided at
fiGlen Rock Bore, York County which is location where the incident is alleged
to have occurred.

 

According to publicly available records, the defendant has served as Magisterial District Judge
presiding over District Court 1973--04 beginning in January of 2012 after being elected to that position
on November 2011. The defendant has sewed in this official capacity through the present date.
Additionally, the defendant's public safety experience includes sewing ten years as the former
chairman of the Southern Police Commission. He also served as the former Mayor of New Freedom
Borough for ten years and was previously a dispatcher with York County 911 for two years

The following are the facts of this case developed primarily from personal interviews that were
conducted with the victim, the defendant, and other witnesses identified through this investigation
who were able to illustrate an ongoing course of conduct and mistreatment relative to the defendant's
interactions with female court participants, and who further corroborate the victim's allegations:

-CONTINUED-

1, TPR. JONATHAN COLARUSSO, BEING DULY SWORN ACCORDING TO THE LAW, DEPOSE AND SAY THAT
THE FACTS SET FORTH IN THE FOREGOING AFFIDAVIT ARE TRUE AND CORRE BEST OF MY
KNOWLEDGE. INFORMATION AND BELIEF.

   

 

        

(Slgnalt'mm'fiymhu

i


Sworn to me and subscribed before me this 7 day of A fig PIS Tl?
62. 
Dale 19'? 

day ofJanuary. 9 em to 
31,434:

   
 
 

 
 
  

My commission expires tir

 

 

6
@4001". met" 




 

73m 4116 . Rev. omo Page 1 mg

 

 POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
'x AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE

Docket Numb ate File her: Number
I H7-2369191

First: Last:
I Derendant Name: Jamey Sm" JOY

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION

On 03/04/15 at 1933 hours, your affiant conducted an interview with the victim -at the PSP York
Station. - related that she first met MDJ JOY on 02/19/15 at District Court 19--3-04 while she was
under sub oena as a victim/Witness for the Commonwealth tor a criminal case involving her
boyfriend_ who was the case defendant. In a negotiated plea agreement,
-- plead guilty to two summary Non-Traffic violations tor Disorderly Conduct and
Harassment. in exchange, the misdemeanor charge of Simple Assault was withdrawn. As a result of
the plea. District Court 1973-04 maintained control of this case because_ owed 
court in excess of $1 .000 in fines and costs. Although the--case was adjudicated, he
remained in the custody ot York County Prison indefinitely due to a probation violation and was
attempting to gain approval for the work release program.

After the court proceeding described above,- said she approached JOY and re orted an incident
involving her suspicion that child abuse was occurring in an adjoining apartment. informed JOY
that she could hear the abuse occurring through the walls of her apartment. JOY provided her with
his business card and advised-to contact him it she heard anything else.

- related that during the afternoon hours of 02/19/15 (atter the above referenced preliminary
hearing concluded), JOY drove his personal vehicle to the apartments located at--and
encotlntered- outside. At first, -said she didn't recognize JOY until he identified himself as
"Judge Joy." -said she and JOY conversed briefly and he asked - it he could come inside her
apartment to talk. Once-allowed JOY inside. she suggested having her next door neighbor
come over so that the neighbor could provide additional information regarding the child abuse matter.
JOY told that he didn't want anyone to know he was there because he was attempting to
contirm earlier report that the alleged child abuse could be heard from inside the walls other
apartment. During this encounter,- related both she and JOY did in fact hear yelling through the
walls by an adult from the downstairs apartment in question. Accordin to-, JOY stayed at her
apartment for approximately 20-30 minutes. Prior to JOY leavingi said JOY asked her if she
needed any money for rent or tood. He also asked about her workout routine and commented that
she had a nice bod . JOY hugged -and told her to call him if she needed anything or heard
anything funher.i related in her statement that she felt uncomfortable with this encounter.

 

-CONTINUED-

       

2, O,
(signs/tut; yr


0
"mo/V



  

AOPC 411C -Rev.07l10 W'Pageziorfi

 

 

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Filed: OTN/leescan Number: Complaint/Incident Number
I H7-2369I91
First: Middle: Last:
Defendant Name: Jamey Sm" Jov

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION

then reported the 3/04/15 at 1454 hours, she received a phone call from the District Court
04 office number. answered this phone call, which was placed by JOY. The call lasted 8
minutes. JOY initially advised - that she needed to provide a formal statement to the Southern
Regional Police Depanment regardin the alleged child abuse case. The conversation then
developed into JOY asking about finances and wellbelng. She indicated she was stru ling
and needed to lind another part time job. JOY then asked if she had any artwork for sale. '9
responded affirmatively, and said JOY asked it he could stop by later and buy a painting to help her
out financially. -agreed to this request.

 

 

On 03/04/15 at approximately 16154630 hours.- said JOY arrived at her apartment. She
allowed him inside and began showing him her artwork. - indicated that JOY asked her
repeatedly if she had any self-portraits that displayed rlattoos. She told JOY she did not, but said
she had custom pin-up drawings that resemble her. then showed JOY one of the custom pin--
ups that were on her computer. This particular pin-Up girl was posed in a sexually suggestive position
while wearing a pair of stockings, which became the topic of conversation. indicated that she
had a similar pair of stockings and said that JOY asked her to put them on- related she initially
said no to this request, but began to fear tha upset JOY. then her boyfriend could face
additional punishment for his criminal cases then walked to her bedroom to change and closed
the bedroom (loot-said that JOY walked back to her bedroom uninvited, opened the door and
entered her bedroom while she was pulling the stockings up wearing only underwear and a shirt.

said she panicked and reached into her closet to find clothes to cover herself. She said JOY
approached her and groped her backside and breast and then offered her "$15000" to take off her
shirt so that he could see her tattoos without clothin said she refused, but advised thal JOY
pulled up her shirt anyway and licked her breasts, reported that the described sexual contact
occurred without her permission or consent. - said she ran out of the room and opened the front
door for JOY to leave. immediately following the sexual encounter, she reported what occurred to her
next door neighbor and made a prompt complaint to PSP the same evening,

 



 

 

4116 -Rev. 07110 Pageiofh

 

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE 7

  

 

 

 

 

'o'ocket Number: Date Filed: OTN/LiveScau Number Complaint/Incident Number
H772369191
- 
Defendant Name: Easy 3g? 

 

 

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION

On 03/05/15 at 1057 hours, I interviewed JOY relative to this investigation, He said he first met-
through District Court proceedings and acknowledged that he traveled to -'s apartment on
02/19/15 and 03/04/15, confirming .5 statement with a relative degree of consistency regarding
their personal and phone interactions. However, when JOY was questioned about the critical event
regarding an alleged sexual encounter with- he was evasive and deceptive. As evidenceI JOY
provided three different versions of the same event. In his first statement detailing the encounter.
JOY said he drove to-S apartment on 03/04/15 and arrived between 16i5xsd 

-CONTINUED--

  
    

 

   

   

07m Page {if

 

 

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
. CONTINUATION PAGE

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Flled: OTNlLiveScan Number: 
H7-23691et
Firsl: Middle: LasI

Defendant Name: Jamey JOY

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION

I then asked JOY if anythin else happened between him and. He responded, "i think that was
it." After informing JOY that was taken to York Hospital where body swabs were collected for
DNA, asked him if he would be able to explain it if his saliva or DNA was found on her chest or
body. In response to this question, JOY then provided a third version of events and stated, may
have kissed her breast," JOY insisted that this was the extent of the physical contact he had with
- He believed the encounter to be consensualI and stated menl in a
judicial capacity, but admitted that he shouldn't have gotten involved or been [to 's apartment].

JOY also refuted 's claim that he offered her $150 dollars to remove her clothing. He ex lained
that he only had a ew dollars on him, even though his initial reasoning for why he went toi's
apartment was specifically to purchase artwork to help her financial situation.

Furthermore, JOY stated that the above described encounters with - were the only occasions
where he made personal visits a court participant at their home. This answer was later determined to
be a lie after your affiant interviewed an adult female identified as -
advised that she has been in Judge court as a defendant on several occasions, and only knew
him from in-court appearances. She recalled a 2013 hearing where JOY told her she was "too pretty"
to be in his court tor drug charges and said JOY referred to her as being pretty more than once
during the hearing, Atter this hearing, - said JOY made two or three personal visits to her
apartment. She said JOY sometimes stayed at her apartment for 1>>2 hours- said she still had
active cases in court at the time of these personal visits where she owed fines. During his
personal visits to her home-said JOY would ask how she was doing financially and provided her
and her mother information regarding local services that could assist them.- thought it was
unusual for a MDJ to visit a court defendant at their apartment, especially when she had active

cases and said that the information he provided to her was something that could have been done in
court. also described a conversation that occurred at her home where JOY offered to take her
and her mother out to Red Lobster if she stayed out of trouble. She said JOY called her cell phone
on more than one occasions to check on herwell-being and to see if she needed a ride for court
appearances or community sen/ice. - said JOY never made any sexual advances towards her,
but added that her mother was always present on the occasions when JOY came to her apartment.
-described JOY as being "overly caring." She thought it was unusual and said it was "too much"
for a Judge to be that concerned for her wellvbeing.



    

2 $lgriatuie aiAmamf
C, . .

. 








AOPC 4110 -- Rev,07/1tl Pages~ olfL

 

 

POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE

 

 

 

Docket Number: Date Filed: OTN/leeScan Number: 
I H7-2369191 7
First: Middle. Last'

Defendant Name: Jamey Sm" Joy

 

 

 

 

AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION

Additionall investi ators from the Judicial Conduct Board met with an adult female identified as
fi-also reported that she only knew JOY by appearing before him in court.
In her statement-indicated that she appeared before JOY on three separate occasions
beginning in 2014, and described a series ofunusual and inappropriate behavior and comments
made by JOY towards her all stemming from in-court appearancss, According to -, during a traffic
violation hearing JOY said to her in open court, "This officer did you a favor because you are a pretty
girl". said she felt uncomfortable since it was only thejudge, the officer, and -, in the
courtroom, Then, on January 2015, - said she and JOY were alone together in the courtroom
of District Court 19-3-04 when JOY made inappropriate sexual comments to her at the conclusion of
a hearing intended to resolve a fine payment issue. -said that she was called to the bench by
JOY, and he asked her it she uses drugs -said she did not use drugs and hardly drinks. JOY
then aske-if she smokes-responded affirmatively, but said she wished she didn't, JOY
then replied, "You know that they say about girls that smoke". replied, JOY said, "They
like things in their mouths, do you like things in your mouth?' reported she was taken aback by
what JOYjust said to her and replied, "i like candy." JOY then said, "Is that all?"- also said JOY
commented about how they would have fun ifthey attended a party together, but admitted that she
could not remember the exact words because she was upset and wanted to leave. -stated she
was so "disgusted and flustered" that she asked if she was excused and left the courtroom.

During the aforementioned interview with JOY, he had also stated that he referred the alleged child
abuse incident to Detective SHAFER of the Southern Regional Police Department and lo Childline on
02/20/15. JOY indicated that approximately one week later (02/26/15). he was notified that York
County Children Youth and Families investigated and closed the child abuse investigation due to a
lack of disclosure by both the victim and alleged perpetrator.

In an effort to confirm account of his report to law enforcement, your atfiant conducted
interviews with DetectiVe William SHAFER and Officer Michael STOREMAN of the Southern
Regional Police Department. Both Detective SHAFER and Officer STOREMAN recall JOY making a
request for investigation to their agency regarding an alleged child abuse case on or about 02/20/15.
However, the officers were never notified by JOY that he went to apartment and conducted an
investigation, and JOY never reported his observations that he overheard yelling and commotion in
the downstairs apartment on 02/19/15.

Criminal charges contained within the attached criminal complaint were approved by the Office of
Attorney General which has assumed jurisdiction of this prosecution under the Commonwealth
Attorneys Act, Your afflant believes the above information establishes probable causeufyolrv the
charges listed in the preceding criminal complaint. and believes the information this
document to be true and correct. I respectfully request the initiation of due pro s'uor, the defendant,
Jeffrey Scott JOY. i 

   
 

  

 

mafia . Rev. 07110