A publication of the Greater Houston Partnership Volume 24 Number 7— July 2015 Timing is Everything — Last December, the Greater Houston Partnership forecast the nine-county Houston metro area would create 62,900 jobs by year’s end. If the year had ended on Memorial Day, the forecast would be near the mark. For the 12 months ending May ’15, Houston created 62,300 jobs, a 2.1 percent annual increase. However, the year is barely halfway over and only five months of jobs data have been released to date. More importantly, economic conditions have changed dramatically since the Partnership issued its original forecast. Those changes warrant the Partnership revisiting and revising its jobs outlook for this year. The original forecast was based on several assumptions:  The North American rig count would fall by 500 rigs this year. It has lost more than 1,000 since its September ’14 peak.  The energy industry would cut exploration expenditures by 25 percent. The cuts now approach 40 percent.  Exports would continue to grow. Through April of this year, exports via the HoustonGalveston Customs District slipped 13.1 percent compared to last year.  Houston’s population growth would continue. Judging by the out-of-state license plates in the IKEA parking lot on Saturday night, that hasn’t changed.  And others sectors had sufficient momentum to sustain job growth well into ’15. Judging by the various indicators, that momentum has somewhat abated. Houston will not experience job growth to the extent the Partnership originally forecast for this year, but the region will create jobs. Details of the revised outlook follow. A Close Look at the Data — The Texas Workforce Commission (TWC) reports jobs data on a month-to-month and annualized basis, i.e., over the preceding 12 months. Monthly data, however, don’t reflect trends, and 12-month totals can be misleading, especially if growth in the early months differs greatly from that in the later months. That’s the case with Houston. Though the metro area created 62,300 jobs in the 12 months ending May ’15, most of those jobs came in the second half of ’14. Examining changes from the employment peak in each sector offers a more accurate assessment. On that basis, employment in most sectors peaked late last year. In some cases, the losses from the peak are significant. Only leisure and hospitality, health care, government and information continue to add jobs. If not for growth in those sectors, HouJuly 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 1 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE ston’s outlook would be much worse. For the year to close with a net increase in jobs, the losses in the weakest sectors must stop, some portion of those losses must be recouped, and growth must continue in the healthiest sectors. Given historic patterns, that will be difficult, but not impossible. CHANGE IN METRO HOUSTON EMPLOYMENT The Typical Cycle — Total nonfarm SELECTED SECTORS payroll employment peaked in DeEmployment Employment Sector Peak Change* cember ’14, then lost 47,000 jobs in Leisure and Hospitality Growing +16,900 January ’15. That’s about normal for Health Care Growing +4,800 Houston. All sectors (save one) report Government Growing +3,400 losses the first month of the year, but Information Growing +1,500 six bear the brunt of the layoffs: retail, Manufacturing Dec ’14 -9,200 finance, business services, administra- Mining and Logging Dec ’14 -7,100 Dec ’14 -4,900 tive support (e.g., janitorial and con- Retail Construction Oct ’14 -4,500 tract work), leisure and hospitality Dec ’14 -4,500 (e.g., restaurants and bars), and public Transport, Warehousing, Utilities Dec ’14 -2,500 education. Only the accounting sector Wholesale Trade Finance and Real Estate Oct ’14 -2,300 consistently adds jobs in January, as Business Services Aug ’14 -1,900 CPA firms gear up for tax season. Other Services Jun ’14 -1,100 Broad-based hiring typically resumes * Gains measured from December ’14; losses measured from previous peak, in February, accelerates in March, and Source: Partnership calculations based on Texas Workforce Commission data. normally by April employment returns to its previous peak. The pattern can be seen below. This isn’t a typical year, however. When TWC released data for May, Houston remained 7,300 jobs below December’s total. At this point in the cycle, Houston should be 12,000 to 15,000 jobs above its previous peak. Stated another way, year-to-date employment growth is at least 20,000 jobs Total Nonfarm Payroll Employment, Houston Metro Area short of where it should be. 3.1 3.0 Jobs, Millions 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.4 2.3 2.2 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 '16 Employment usually grows in June. In robust years (’11, ’12 and ’13), the region adds 10,000 to 12,000 jobs. In weak years (’04, ’05, ’08), the region adds 6,000 to 8,000. So when TWC reports June employment, if Houston finally surpasses the December peak, it won’t be by much. Source: Texas Workforce Commission July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 2 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE Expect payroll employment to lose ground again in July. The education sector, where 10month contracts are common, always incurs losses as teachers, instructional aids and cafeteria workers fall off school district payrolls in the summer. Combined with smaller seasonal losses elsewhere, July’s cuts have averaged 13,600 jobs over the past 10 years. The Bright Spot — Houston’s employment always grows in the fall, even in a recession. Over the past decade, 50 to 60 percent of Houston’s job growth has occurred between September and December. That’s not surprising given the seasonal job losses earlier in the year. Barring any surprises, nonfarm payroll employment should return to peak by the end of the third quarter. If history repeats itself, and there’s no reason to think it won’t, Houston should see gains in retail, wholesale, transportation, business services, health care, restaurants and bars and public education in the fall. Even in ’09, the worst recession since the ’80s, Houston added 17,300 jobs in the final months of the year. Houston should enter the fall of ’15 in better health than it entered the fall of ’09. What to Expect — Retailers always ramp up for the Christmas shopping season. Employment agencies will place contract workers with companies that need extra help meeting year-end deadlines. After a summer hiring lull, service firms will focus on filling essential open positions. Any increase in business activity will create work for truck drivers and shipping clerks. Hospitals and clinics will continue to staff up to meet the needs of Houston’s growing population. New campuses and expanding enrollments will require more teachers and classroom aids. Restaurants and bars will take on seasonal wait staff to handle holiday parties. Employment in oil field services may inch up as lease terms require production companies to drill new wells before year’s end. But don’t expect an increase in manufacturing jobs. Plant managers are more likely to pay overtime than hire additional staff. So what does job growth look like in the second half of the year?  In a booming economy, Houston might create 50,000 to 60,000 jobs in the fall.  In a recovering economy, Houston might create 30,000 to 40,000 jobs in the waning months.  In a soft economy, the region might add 20,000 to 30,000 jobs. Reading the Signals — Weakness in various sectors, not just energy, indicate a soft economy and that suggests the lower of the three ranges of job growth this year. Local auto dealers sold fewer vehicles in the first five months of ’15 than in the comparable period in ’14. City of Houston construction permits peaked in the 12 months ending in February and have trended downward since. Realtors sold fewer single-family homes in May of this year than last. Transwestern estimates the amount of sublease office space on the market has nearly doubled over the past 12 months. And the Houston Purchasing ManagJuly 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 3 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE ers Index (PMI), a leading indicator for regional production, registered 46.1 in May. Readings below 50 suggest contraction in the near term. May’s PMI does reflect an improvement from April’s reading of 42.7. SELECTED HOUSTON ECONOMIC INDICATORS Indicator Purchasing Managers Index Customs District Exports $ Billions, April Year-to-Date City of Houston Construction Permits $ Billions, Year-to-Date May ’15 May ’14 %∆ 46.1 59.2 - 37.827 43.516 -13.1 3.145 3.644 -13.7 Not all is gloom and doom, howev- Sales Tax Collections, City of Hous284.1 270.1 +5.1 er. Oil prices have stabilized. The ton, $ Millions, Year-to-Date Airport System Traffic 21.637 21.251 +1.8 fall in the rig count appears to have Houston Total Passengers, Millions, Year-to-Date hit bottom. The fleet actually added Apartment Occupancy 91.2 91.1 rigs the third week of June. Center- All Classes (A, B,C & D), % Point continues to sign up new cus- Apartment Rental Rates 1.09 1.024 +6.4 Class A, $/Sq. Ft. tomers and electricity consumption Hotel Occupancy 71.6 73.6 is up for the year. Traffic through Average %, Houston MSA, Q1/14 v Q1/15 the Houston Airport System con- Motor Vehicle Sales 154,394 163,502 -5.6 tinues to grow. With only a 3.1 Total Units, Year-to-Date Single-Family Home Sales 27,869 28,224 -1.3 month supply of homes on the Houston Market, Year-to-Date market there’s little danger of near- Median Price, Single Family Home 206,554 190,098 +8.6 term overbuilding. (A 6.0 month $, Houston Market, YTD Average inventory 3.1 2.8 supply is considered a balanced Single-family Months of supply market.) Apartment occupancy and Unemployment Rate 4.2 5.0 lease rates are holding firm (good Unadjusted (%) Payroll Employment news for landlords but bad news for Nonfarm 2.1 2.9 Annualized Growth Rate (%) tenants). At 4.2 percent, Houston’s Sources: Institute for Supply Management - Houston, WISERTrade, Kiley Advisors, Houston May unemployment rate is well be- Airport System, Apartment Data Services, PKF Consulting, TexAuto Facts, Houston Association of Realtors, Texas Workforce Commission low the 5.3 percent national average. And several respondents to a June Texas manufacturing survey told the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas they believed the worst was over for the oil and gas industry. The Forecast — Given the softness in the local economy, the Partnership anticipates the region will gain 20,000 to 30,000 jobs this year, not as robust as previous years but still in positive territory. As with the Partnership’s earlier forecast, the revised outlook is based on a number of assumptions. Oil prices, though they may experience short-term volatility, average $60 or above the remainder of the year. The rig count has bottomed out. The majority of the energy-related layoffs have taken place. Local business confidence holds firm. Consumer spending slows only moderately. The U.S. economy expands at an annual rate of 2.5 percent or better the remainder of the year. And any geopolitical events that occur—Greece exiting from the Eurozone, a downturn in China’s economy, major terrorist attack overseas—have a limited impact on the U.S. economy. July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 4 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE The Forecast in Context — Those who have lived and worked in Houston for a quarter century or more recognize the resilience of the local economy. Since ’90, Houston has experienced in only four years of net job losses. With the exception of ’09, a global recession that no industry, metro or nation could avoid, Houston’s losses in a downturn tended to be mild. Net Change in Houston Emloyment December to December, 000s 118.5 107.0 98.4 92.8 44.3 18.7 91.1 104.7 90.7 82.9 62.3 59.7 53.4 54.4 53.0 89.9 49.7 39.3 10.6 -8.1 21.6 17.8 1.3 -1.7 -11.6 -110.6 '90 '91 '92 '93 '94 '95 '96 '97 '98 '99 '00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15* Source: Texas Workforce Commission * for the 12 months ending May '15 Even with the downturns, Houston has compiled an impressive history of growth. From January ’90 to the present, Houston has added more than 1.2 million jobs, gained 2.7 million residents, and quadrupled the size of its gross regional product. Houston accomplished this as oil prices went from $22.86 per barrel (Jan ’90) to $11.35 (Dec ’98) to $133.88 per barrel (June ’08) to $59.29 (December ’14). Houston now faces a short period of uncertainty—perhaps six to 18 months—but the region has a long track record of impressive growth. The factors that supported that growth remain intact, assuring that this year's slowdown is a lull, not a new normal. July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 5 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE SNAPSHOT — HOUSTON’S KEY ECONOMIC INDICATORS Building Permits — City of Houston construction permits totaled $8.2 billion for the 12 months ending May ’15, up 10.6 percent from $7.4 billion for the 12 months ending May ’14, according to the latest data released by the city’s Department of Public Works & Engineering Planning & Development Services. Despite May’s running total exceeding last year’s total, construction has trended downward since the first of the year, with total construction peaking at $8.9 billion in February. Inflation — The cost of consumer goods and services as measured by the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) was unchanged nationwide from May ’14 to May ’15 according to data released today by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Core inflation (all items less the volatile food and energy categories) rose 1.7 percent over the past 12 months. Home Sales — The Houston housing market experienced a mixed bag of indicators in May. Year-over-year, single family home sales and total property sales declined while total dollar volume remained flat. However, home prices reached record highs for the Houston area. Single-family home sales declined 4.3 percent from 7,110 in May ’14 to 6,807 in May ’15. Meanwhile, the average price of a single-family home grew 4.5 percent from $279,442 in May ’14 to $292,040 in May ’15. During the same period, the median price of a singlefamily home rose 10.5 percent to $223,000. Purchasing Managers Index — The Houston Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), a shortterm leading indicator for regional production, registered 46.1 in May, an increase from 42.7 in April, according to the latest report from the Institute for Supply Management-Houston (ISM-Houston). After two months of declines, Houston’s PMI registered its first month-tomonth increase in May. Vehicle Sales — Houston-area auto dealers sold 33,517 vehicles in May ’15, an 8.1 percent decrease from the 36,465 sold May ’14, according to TexAuto Facts, published by InfoNation, Inc. of Sugar Land. Over the first five months of ’15, vehicle sales totaled 154,394, a 5.6 percent decrease from the 163,502 sold in the first five months of ’14. Patrick Jankowski and Jenny Philip contributed to this issue of Houston: The Economy at a Glance July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 6 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE Stay Up To Date! To access past issues of Economy at a Glance, please click here. If you are a nonmember and would like to receive this electronic publication, please email your request for Economy at a Glance to echambers@houston.org. Include your name, title and phone number and your company’s name and address. For information about joining the Greater Houston Partnership, call Member Services at 713-844-3683. The Key Economic Indicators table is updated whenever any data change — typically, 11 or so times per month. If you would like to receive these updates by e-mail, usually accompanied by commentary, please email your request for Key Economic Indicators to echambers@houston.org with the same identifying information. You may request Glance and Indicators in the same email. July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 7 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE HOUSTON MSA NONFARM PAYROLL EMPLOYMENT (000) Change from Apr '15 May '14 % Change from Apr '15 May '14 May '15 Apr '15 May '14 2,985.3 2,598.2 563.8 2,421.5 2,034.4 2,971.6 2,584.5 569.0 2,402.6 2,015.5 2,923.0 2,543.5 565.2 2,357.8 1,978.3 13.7 13.7 -5.2 18.9 18.9 62.3 54.7 -1.4 63.7 56.1 0.5 0.5 -0.9 0.8 0.9 2.1 2.2 -0.2 2.7 2.8 Mining and Logging Oil & Gas Extraction Support Activities for Mining 108.4 54.7 52.9 110.5 54.3 54.7 108.6 53.9 53.4 -2.1 0.4 -1.8 -0.2 0.8 -0.5 -1.9 0.7 -3.3 -0.2 1.5 -0.9 Construction 205.9 206.4 203.6 -0.5 2.3 -0.2 1.1 Manufacturing Durable Goods Manufacturing Nondurable Goods Manufacturing 249.5 168.4 81.1 252.1 170.8 81.3 253.0 173.4 79.6 -2.6 -2.4 -0.2 -3.5 -5.0 1.5 -1.0 -1.4 -0.2 -1.4 -2.9 1.9 Wholesale Trade 169.9 170.4 167.0 -0.5 2.9 -0.3 1.7 Retail Trade 303.8 298.5 290.1 5.3 13.7 1.8 4.7 Transportation, Warehousing and Utilities Utilities Air Transportation Truck Transportation Pipeline Transportation 134.5 16.0 20.3 25.7 10.5 133.9 16.0 20.3 25.5 10.5 133.3 15.7 20.5 24.6 10.2 0.6 0.0 0.0 0.2 0.0 1.2 0.3 -0.2 1.1 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.8 0.0 0.9 1.9 -1.0 4.5 2.9 Information Telecommunications 33.7 14.9 34.3 15.0 33.1 15.1 -0.6 -0.1 0.6 -0.2 -1.7 -0.7 1.8 -1.3 Finance & Insurance 94.7 93.9 93.2 0.8 1.5 0.9 1.6 Real Estate & Rental and Leasing 52.6 52.7 54.3 -0.1 -1.7 -0.2 -3.1 469.6 221.6 25.1 22.9 75.1 32.5 214.9 203.1 77.3 464.3 222.5 25.2 24.7 76.0 32.3 208.7 197.2 73.9 463.2 215.1 23.6 21.8 73.2 32.3 214.1 203.4 80.9 5.3 -0.9 -0.1 -1.8 -0.9 0.2 6.2 5.9 3.4 6.4 6.5 1.5 1.1 1.9 0.2 0.8 -0.3 -3.6 1.1 -0.4 -0.4 -7.3 -1.2 0.6 3.0 3.0 4.6 1.4 3.0 6.4 5.0 2.6 0.6 0.4 -0.1 -4.4 54.5 55.1 52.5 -0.6 2.0 -1.1 3.8 Health Care & Social Assistance 309.8 307.3 296.6 2.5 13.2 0.8 4.5 Arts, Entertainment & Recreation 33.5 31.0 31.8 2.5 1.7 8.1 5.3 Accommodation & Food Services 273.4 270.2 258.5 3.2 14.9 1.2 5.8 Other Services 104.4 103.9 104.7 0.5 -0.3 0.5 -0.3 Government Federal Government State Government State Government Educational Services Local Government Local Government Educational Services 387.1 27.9 72.4 39.8 286.8 199.9 387.1 28.0 73.4 40.3 285.7 200.1 379.5 27.6 72.1 39.6 279.8 195.1 0.0 -0.1 -1.0 -0.5 1.1 -0.2 7.6 0.3 0.3 0.2 7.0 4.8 0.0 -0.4 -1.4 -1.2 0.4 -0.1 2.0 1.1 0.4 0.5 2.5 2.5 Total Nonfarm Payroll Jobs Total Private Goods Producing Service Providing Private Service Providing Professional & Business Services Professional, Scientific & Technical Services Legal Services Accounting, Tax Preparation, Bookkeeping Architectural, Engineering & Related Services Computer Systems Design & Related Services Admin & Support/Waste Mgt & Remediation Administrative & Support Services Employment Services Educational Services SOURCE: Texas Workforce Commission July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 8 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE Houston Economic Indicators A Service of the Greater Houston Partnership YEAR-TO-DATE TOTAL or YTD AVERAGE* MONTHLY DATA Month Most Recent ENERGY U.S. Active Rotary Rigs Spot Crude Oil Price ($/bbl, West Texas Intermediate) Spot Natural Gas ($/MMBtu, Henry Hub) May '15 May '15 May '15 889 59.47 2.83 1,859 102.23 4.53 -52.2 -41.8 -37.5 1,194 * 52.08 * 2.82 * 1,808 * 100.22 * 4.76 * -34.0 -48.0 -40.8 UTILITIES AND PRODUCTION Houston Purchasing Managers Index Nonresidential Electric Current Sales (Mwh, CNP Service Area) May '15 May '15 46.1 4,904,644 59.2 4,237,991 -22.1 15.7 46.3 * 21,829,118 58.3 * 20,742,066 -20.6 5.2 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 1,406,295,000 689,120,000 717,175,000 596,954,584 414,981,705 279,544,525 135,437,180 181,972,879 163,549,276 18,423,603 1,699,246,000 784,500,000 914,746,000 971,764,397 604,507,316 439,366,231 165,141,085 367,257,081 340,298,206 26,958,875 -17.2 -12.2 -21.6 -38.6 -31.4 -36.4 -18.0 -50.5 -51.9 -31.7 May '15 May '15 May '15 8,278 223,000 30,550 8,642 201,750 28,712 -4.2 10.5 6.4 33,913 206,554 * 28,618 * May '15 May '15 May '15 2,985,300 563,800 2,421,500 2,923,000 565,200 2,357,800 2.1 -0.2 2.7 2,968,260 * 571,320 0 2,396,940 0 May '15 May '15 May '15 4.2 4.1 5.3 5.0 5.1 6.1 Apr '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 May '15 4,811,422 4,647,516 3,781,921 865,595 67,853 33,411 17,839 15,571 3,937,494 4,622,072 3,765,525 856,547 68,909 35,509 18,769 16,739 22.2 0.6 0.4 1.1 -1.5 -5.9 -5.0 -7.0 16,509,814 21,635,312 17,517,228 4,118,084 328,755 177,002 92,524 84,478 14,742,516 21,251,961 17,251,365 4,000,596 335,892 175,130 92,904 82,227 12.0 1.8 1.5 2.9 -2.1 1.1 -0.4 2.7 May '15 May '15 May '15 4Q14 33,517 13,427 20,090 34,260 36,465 15,593 20,872 37,618 -8.1 -13.9 -3.7 -8.9 154,394 63,806 90,588 123 163,502 70,052 93,450 116 -5.6 -8.9 -3.1 5.6 May '15 May '15 212.4 237.805 213.3 237.9 -0.4 0.0 211.300 * 235.790 * 212.100 * 235.992 * -0.4 -0.1 4Q14 4Q14 4Q14 68.1 106.52 72.49 65.9 101.26 66.77 5.2 8.6 71.8 * 106.87 * 76.76 * 69.1 * 101.19 * 69.92 * 5.6 9.8 CONSTRUCTION Total Building Contracts ($, Houston MSA) Nonresidential Residential Building Permits ($, City of Houston) Nonresidential New Nonresidential Nonresidential Additions/Alterations/Conversions Residential New Residential Residential Additions/Alterations/Conversions Multiple Listing Service (MLS) Activity Property Sales Median Sales Price - SF Detached Active Listings EMPLOYMENT (Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown MSA) Nonfarm Payroll Employment Goods Producing (Natural Resources/Mining/Const/Mfg) Service Providing Unemployment Rate (%) - Not Seasonally Adjusted Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown MSA Texas U.S. TRANSPORTATION Port of Houston Authority Shipments (Short Tons) Air Passengers (Houston Airport System) Domestic Passengers International Passengers Landings and Takeoffs Air Freight (metric tons) Enplaned Deplaned CONSUMERS New Car and Truck Sales (Units, Houston MSA) Cars Trucks, SUVs and Commercials Total Retail Sales ($000,000, Houston MSA, NAICS Basis) Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers ('82-'84=100) Houston-Galveston-Brazoria CMSA United States Hotel Performance (Houston MSA) Occupancy (%) Average Room Rate ($) Revenue Per Available Room ($) July 2015 Year % Earlier Change Most Recent 7,131,277,000 2,934,192,000 4,197,085,000 3,145,907,862 2,034,041,660 1,165,194,217 868,847,443 1,111,866,202 1,014,014,229 97,851,973 4.2 * 4.2 * 5.6 * ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Year Earlier % Change 11,935,662,000 7,790,228,000 4,145,434,000 3,644,067,547 2,425,455,752 1,573,542,661 851,913,091 1,218,611,795 1,085,846,664 132,765,131 -40.3 -62.3 1.2 -13.7 -16.1 -26.0 2.0 -8.8 -6.6 -26.3 34,468 190,098 * 28,712 * -1.6 8.7 -0.3 2,884,980 * 557,940 * 2,327,040 * 2.9 2.4 3.0 5.2 * 5.4 * 6.6 * Page 9 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE Sources Rig Count Spot WTI, Spot Natural Gas Houston Purchasing Managers Index Baker Hughes Incorporated U.S. Energy Information Admin. National Association of Purchasing Management – Houston, Inc. Electricity CenterPoint Energy Building Construction Contracts McGraw-Hill Construction City of Houston Building Permits Building Permit Department, City of Houston MLS Data Houston Association of Realtors Employment, Unemployment Texas Workforce Commission July 2015 Port Shipments Aviation Car and Truck Sales Retail Sales Consumer Price Index Hotels Postings, Foreclosures ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Port of Houston Authority Aviation Department, City of Houston TexAuto Facts Report, InfoNation, Inc., Sugar Land TX Texas Comptroller’s Office U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics PKF Consulting/HospitalityAsset Advisors International Foreclosure Information &Listing Service Page 10 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE 3,000 150 2,900 120 2,800 90 2,700 60 2,600 30 2,500 0 2,400 -30 2,300 -60 2,200 -90 2,100 -120 2,000 12-Month Change (000) Nonfarm Payroll Employment (000) Nonfarm Payroll Employment, Houston MSA -150 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 12-Month Change '12 '13 '14 '15 '16 Total Payroll Employment Source: Texas Workforce Commission Goods-Producing and Service-Providing Employment Houston MSA 620 2,500 2,300 540 2,200 2,100 500 2,000 460 Service-Providing Jobs (000s) Goods-Producing Jobs (000s) 2,400 580 1,900 420 1,800 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 Goods-Producing Jobs '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 '16 Service-Providing Jobs Source: Texas Workforce Commission July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 11 HOUSTON—THE ECONOMY AT A GLANCE Unemployment Rate - Houston, Texas and U.S. 11 10 % Civilian Labor Force 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 Houston '11 '12 Texas '13 '14 '15 '16 U.S. Source: Texas Workforce Commission Spot Crude and Natural Gas Prices 160 16 140 14 120 12 100 10 80 8 60 6 40 4 20 2 0 0 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 Natural Gas, $ /mcf WTI, $ barrel Monthly Averages '16 WTI Natural Gas Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration July 2015 ©2015, Greater Houston Partnership Page 12