DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION - wwv:.dot.5tate. pa . US Hand delivered date: December 23, 2014 David Ingram lngram?s Service Center 411 New Park Rd New Park, PA 17352 ORDER OF SUSPENSION OF OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTION STATION in compliance with the Stipulation Agreement and Settlement, the suspension of your emission inspection station privileges has been af?rmed. In accordance with this decision, you are hereby suspended for two (2) months for improper inspection and two (2) months for im ro er record keeping (1999 Lexus VIN JT8BF2860X0147240 by David lngram Operator ?ssued sticker [Ms-1866859) with credit given for fourteen (14) days already served. The suspension(s) will run concurrently, for a total suspension of one (1) month and sixteen (16) days. This suspension is to run consecutively with any other suspension(s) imposed by the Department for any violation(s) considered separately. You are ordered to surrender to the Quality Assurance Of?cer, who is a representative of the Department of Transportation, your Emission Certi?cate(s) of Appointment, all unused emission inspection stickers and other related emission items. Your emissions inspection equipment will be locked out from performing of?cial emissions testing for the duration of this suspension. Two weeks prior to the expiration of your suspension, you may contact your Quality Assurance Of?cer for reappointment. A complete and thorough investigation may be conducted to determine if you are quali?ed for reappointment. if you have any questions, please contact the Vehicle inspection Division at 717.787.2895 or, you may write to the Vehicle Inspection Division, P. O. Box 68697, Harrisburg, PA 17106-9003. MAILING ADDRESS: Sincerely, Department of Transportation Riverfront Of?ce Center 1101 S. Front Street, 3rd Floor Anita M. Wasko, Director Harrisburg, PA 17104-2416 Bureau of Motor Vehicles Vehicle Inspections 1101 S. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17104 717.787.2895 ma DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION vrvv'.rv'.dot.5tate.pa.us Hand delivered date: December 23, 2014 David In ram (Ingram's Service ORDER OF SUSPENSION OF OFFICIAL INSPECTOR In compliance with the Stipulation Agreement and Settlement, the su5pension of,your inspection privileges has been affirmed. In accordance with this decision, you are hereby suspended for two (2) months for improper inspection and two (2) months for improper record keeping (1999 Lexus VIN JT8BF2860X0147240, issued sticker with credit given for fourteen (14) days already served, The suspension(s) will run concurrently, for a total suspension of one (1) month and sixteen (16) days. This suspension is to run consecutively with any other suspension(s) imposed by the Department for any violation considered separately. You are ordered to surrender to the Quality Assurance Of?cer, who is a representative of the Department of Transportation, your Emission Inspector Certi?cation Card. At the expiration of your suspension, your Emission Inspector Certi?cation Card will be returned to you. If you have any questions, please contact the Vehicle Inspection Division at 717.787.2895 or, you may write to the Vehicle Inspection Division, P. O. Box 69003, Harrisburg, PA 17106-9003. MAILING ADDRESS: Sincerel Department of Transportation Chief Counsei's Of?ce Riverfront Of?ce Center 1101 S. Front Street, 3rd Floor Anita M. Wasko, Director Harrisburg, PA 17104-2416 Bureau of Motor Vehicles Vehicle Inspections 1101 S. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17104 717.787.2895 COMMONWEALTH OF OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL DATE: December 3, 2014 To: Kay Kishbaugh, Manager Vehicle Inspection Division Bureau of Motor Vehicles From: Christopher J. Johnson Assistant Counsel Subject: INSPECTION CASE (EMISSIONS) Station: 0131?: Mechanic: County: Docket Number: Original Sanction: Reason: Notice: ive Date: David Ingram t/d/b/a Ingram's Service Center LLC EA21 David Iniram York 092 AD. 2014 STATION 2 yr $5,000 INSPECTOR 2 yr Furnishing; fraudulent record keeping; improper record keeping; careless record keeping. August 12, 2014 July 29, 2014 August 12, 2014 July 29, 2014 Attached is an Order of Court or a Stipulation. Please take the action indicated: Please modify original sanctions as follows: Emission Station - Rescind 2 year and $5,000 ?ne. Reinstate 2 month susPension for impr0per inspection and improper record keeping with 14 days credit. November 15, 2014. Effective Emission Mechanic Rescind 2 year suspension. Reinstate 2 month suSpension for improper insPection and improper record keeping with 14 days credit. Effective November 15, 2014. If you have any questions, please let me know. Thank you for your assistance. OFFICE OF CHIEF COUNSEL VEHICLE TRAFFIC LAW DIVISION RIVERFRONT OFFICE CENTER, 3RD FLOOR 1101 SOUTH FRONT STREET HARRISBURG, PA 1?104~2516 Ph: 717-737-2830 I Fax: 2174054122 a DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATIO IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY, DAVID F. INGRAM AND No. 2014-SU-003002-27 SERVICE CENTER, LLC - OIS EA21 vs. 1 if; 301,-? - I i i? 80 :1 1:54 [322: 55.4.1: COMMONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, BUREAU OF MOTOR VEHICLES AGREED ORDER WITHDRAWING APPEAL _1 AND NOW, on this 30th day of October, 2014, the appeal ?led at the above docket; ?1 number is hereby WITHDRAWN and DISCONTINUED, with the Department having agreed- to amend the petitioner?s record to re?ect the violations of impmper inspection and improper record-keeping, With a total suspension time of two months (with 14 days already having been served). The suspension shall be effective November 15, 2014. BY THE C0 Attest: Christopher J. Reed, Esq., 135 North George Street, York, PA 17401 Christopher J. Johnson, Esq., Of?ce of Chief Counsel, Riverfront Of?ce Center, 1 101 S. Front Street, Harrisburg, PA 17104?2516 COMMONWEALTH OF OF TRANSPORTATION - HARRISBURG, 17104-2516 RE: DAVID F. INGRAM, INTENT TO NO. 092 AD. 2014 SUSPEND OFFICIAL l- INSPECTOR CERTIFICATION No; PRAECIPE TO SETTLE AND DISCONTINUE APPEAL AND NOW, on this 2nd day of December, 2014, the Respondent Department of Transportation, by and through its counsel, Christopher J. Johnsom ?les this Praecipe to Settle and Discontinue the above captioned appeal, as follows: 1. The parties are in agreement that there will be no need for a hearing in matter, since the parties have agreed to settle the matter as set forth herein. 2. The parties are in agreement that the Department will reinstate a 2 month suspension for - improper inspection and improper record keeping, effective November 15, 2014, with 14 days? credit. WHEREFORE, the Department of Transportation, Bureau of Motor Vehicles respectftu requests that this Honorable Hearing Of?cer enter an order marking this Appeal of Intent to Suspend Of?cial Emission Inspector SETTLED and DISCONTINUED. Assistant Counsel COMNIONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION HARRISBURG, 17104?2516 RE: DAVID F. INGRAM, INTENT SUSPEND OFFICIAL EMISSIONE INSPECTOR CERTIFICATION NO. NO. 092 A.D. 2014 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing Praecipe to Settle and Discontinue Appeal upon the person and in the manner indicated below: First Class Mail: ChlistOpher J. Reed, Esq. CGA Law Firm 135 N. George Street York, PA 17401 DATED: December 2, 2014 Department of Tramportation Of?ce of Chief Counsel 1101 South Front Street - 3d Floor Harrisburg, PA 17104-2516 Telephone: (717) 787~2830 Facsimile: (717) 705-1122 COMMONWEALTH OF OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL August 28, 2014 Christopher .1. Reed, Esquire i?iteensyivaaia CGA Law Firm Seaartarent at Trassgertatrea 135 N. George Street . ME: I York, PA 17401 a as :11 RE: David F. Ingram {State git-eat INTENT TO SUSPEND OFFICIAL INSPECTOR CERTIFICATION N0. 16934776 NO. 092 AD. 2014 Dear Mr. Reed: Receipt of your appeal and request for hearing regarding the Department?s intent to Mr. Ingram?s O?icial Emission InSpector Certi?cation is hereby acknowledged. You will be noti?ed by separate mail of the time and date for the hearing. Any correSpondence or documents to be ?led with this Of?ce must contain the caption as listed above and must consist of an original and two copies. Any documents not meeting these requirements will be returned, without docketing, as de?cient. The Administrative Docket Clerk is responsible for providing the Department Hearing Of?cer with copies of any documents that have been ?led; however, you are resPonsible for serving Department staff counsel, Donald .T. Smith, at the Of?ce of Chief Counsel, 1101 South Front Street, Harrisburg, 17104-2516, as well as any other interested parties. Your documents must contain a proof of service on all parties. Please see 67 Pa. Code, Chapter 491 for more information. cc: Eric J. Jackson, Deparnnent Hearing Of?cer ?onald J- Smith, Assistant Chief Counsel Anita M. Wasko, Director, Bureau of Motor Vehicles Department of Transportation 1 Of?ce of Chief Counsel 1 Administrative Docket FLO. Box 8212] Harrisburg. PA 17105?8212] 717.772.8397 1 Fax: 717.772.2741 A I or capstan-rem o? TRANSPORTATION Christopher J. Reed creed@cgalaw.corn RECEIVED Ext. 156 AUG 2 6 2014 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL - - ~c vavnn COMMONWEALTH OF AUGUSI ADMINISTRATIVE DOCKET DEPARTMENT or: trans-35536? .AHON OFFICE OF CHIEF COUNSEL REF .. . ?3 Administrative Docket Clerk Of?ce of Chief Counsel 400 North Street, 9?h Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120-0096 cm AUG: 6 i=4 Re: Appeal of Of?cial Emission InSpector Suspension To whom it may concern: This law firm represents the interests of David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC with respect to the Notice of Intent to SuSpend Of?cial Emission InSpector letter with a mailed date of July 29, 2014. Please direct any communication regarding this matter to my attention. Please consider this letter as a request for a hearing on the referenced suspension. My client contests that he provided any inspections improperly and that he failed to keep accurate records. Further, my client has consistently maintained his educational requirements and attended numerous seminars in order to remain in compliance with Department of Transportation regulations. Please contact me at your earliest convenience to schedule a hearing on this matter. Best regards, Enclosure CJR/kag cc David F. Ingram {00?36885?lrIf CGA Law Firm, CGA Professional Center, 135 N. George Street, York, PA 17401, 717.848.4900, Fax 717.843.9039, pen DEPARTMENT or: 24b in? - v. Vehicle Inspection Division. p. 0. Box 69003 Dawd F. Ingram Harrisburg PA 17106-9003 18 $332!: 13;; 1 . {Imam 3 8mm Center CERTIFIED MAIL: 70042510000141674864 MAIL DATE: July 29, 2014 . EQTICE 0F INTENT TO SUSPEND OFFICAL EMISSION INSPECTOR -mm no. "Wu?u. . m. 40 You are hereby noti?ed that the intends to suspend your oeni?ca?on as 311 0mm] Emission Inspector pursuant to Section 4726 offne Vehicle Code. IfyOu are: wSpended, no'vehicle omission impoc?ons may be performed dwing a period of suspension. Pursuant to Depamnent regula?ons, tho Depament intends to suspend your ccr??cation as an Of?cial Emission for one you, for ?umish, lend, giv?, sci! or a certi?cate ofemission inspection withOut inSpemion and, one: 1) year for ?audulcnt moord keeping including the lesser offenses of improper record keeping and careless record oping on a (1999 Lexus VIN by David Ingram 0pm sucd sticker 3113-1866359). The: suspensioms) is to run meanively for a total suspension of two years. This suspension is to run consecutiver with my other snspensiong} imposed by the Department for any violation considere? sepamiely. Credit for your suspension term will not begin mail your cer??cazion card is to the Depmbnem. You may contact your Quality Assurance O?cer to mode:- your ocr??cation card or you may maii your certi?cation card IO the Vehicle Inspemion DiVEsion, Post Of?ce Box 69003, Harrisburg, 9A 171063003. Administrative Docket Clerk, Of?ce ofChiefCOunsel, 400 North Street, 9th Floor, Hm?sbuxg, PA 17120?0096. A copy ofthis letter shall accompany the request. ADDITIONALLY, THE ABOVE WILL ALSO BE FINAL AND YOUR CERTIFICATION AS AN OFFICIAL EMISSEON INSPECTOR WILL BE EFFECTIVE August 29. 2014: Anna M. WasI-co, Director Bureau of Motor Vehicles COMMONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION DAVID INGRAM, AppeZZee vs. NO. 092 AD. 2014 COMIVIONWEALTH OF . DEPARTNIENT OF TRANSPORTATION, BUREAU OF MOTOR VEHICLES, Appellant PROOF OF SERVICE I hereby certify thatl have on this day and date duly served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Entry of Appearance upon the person and in the manner indicated, which service satis?es the requirements of Pa. R.A.P. 121: First Class Mail: Postage Pre?Paid; Addressed as Follows: Christopher Reed, Esquire CGA Law Firm CGA Professional Center 135 N. George Street Lonnette McDonald Legal Assistant I Vehicle Tra?c Law Division Department of Transportation O?ce of Chief Counsel River?ont Of?cer Center, Third Floor 1101 South Front Street Harrisburg, 17104425 16 (717)787-2830 Dated: September 16, 2014 COMMONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION I DAVID INGRAIVI, Appeilee vs. No. 092 AD. 2014 COWONWEALTH or - DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, BUREAU OF MOTOR VEHICLES, Appellant ENTRY 0E APPEAMN CE TO THE ADMISTRATIVE DOCKET CLERK: Please enter my appearance on behalf of the Commonwealth of Deparnnent of Transportation, Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Appellant, in the above-entitled matter. Department of Transportation Of?ce of Chief Counsel Riverfront Of?cer Center, Third Floor 1101 South Front Street Harrisburg, 1 7104-25 1 6 (717)787-2830 Dated: September 16, 2014 YIYANIA ur PENNS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPOR . ATION I??elh?? SEP II 2014 COMMONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ADMINISTRATIVE DOCKET COMMONWEALTH KEYSTONE BUILDING 400 NORTH STREET 9TH FLOOR HARRISBURG, 17120-0096 (717) 772-3397 DOCKET OFFICE OF CHIEF COUNSEL. RE: DAVID F. INGRAM INTENT TO SUSPEND OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTOR NO. 092 AD. 2014 CERTIFICATION NO. ORDER AND NOW, this Zi?day of September, 2014, it is hereby ORDERED that the telephone conference originally scheduled for September 24, 2014, is continued to Friday, October 3, 2014, at 10:30 at which time the parties shall dial in Number 1-855-750- 1027 [Local/Harrisburg 717-612-4733], PIN Number 265823#. :0 Please review the enclosed Guidelines for Administrative Proceedings prior to the conference call. 00: en earmg Christopher J. Reed, Esq. (Via facsimile (717) 843-9039 and US. Mail) CGA Law Firm CGA Professional Center 135 North George Street York, PA 17401 Eric J. Jackson, Department Hearing Of?cer Donald J. SmithADreputh?Chief . a :e - I J. "feet m" 'w giacsimne (717) 705-1122 and US. Mail) 35? I3 23E - EALTH OP Rename EEPARI MENI OF TRANSPORTATION COMMONWEALTH OF EMAILED DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ADMINISTRATIVE DOCKET SEP 1 1' 28121 COMMONWEALTH KEYSTONE BUILDING - 400 NORTH STREET - 9TH FLOOR were: re a - 1 HARRISBURG, 17120-0096 QPHQE ?12? LOUNSE (717) 772?8397 RE: DAVID F. INGRAM INTENT TO SUSPEND OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTOR NO. 092 AD. 2014 CERTIFICATION NO.- 2% AND NOW, this [274? day of September, 2014, it is hereby ORDERED that the telephone conference originally scheduled for September 24, 2014, is continued to Friday, October 3, 2014, at 10:30 at which time the parties shall dial in Number 1-855-750- 1027 [Local/Harrisburg 717-612-4733], PIN Number 265823#. Please review the enclosed Guidelines for Administrative Proceedings prior to the conference :m gm Walk-(er. 1 11' view ajgt?eaetze a: maze: i232} . ?ve" IS 20E cc: Christopher J. Reed, Esq. (via facsimile (717) 843-9039 and US. Mail) CGA Law Firm CGA Professional Center 135 North George Street York, PA 17401 Eric J. Jackson, Department Hearing Officer Donald J. Smith, Deputy Chief Counsel Christopher J. Johnson, Assistant Counsel (Via facsimile (717) 705-1122 and US. Mail) Samantha N. Ewing Paralegal sewing@cgalaw.com Ext. 154 August 28, 2014 Department of Transportation Office of Chief Counsel Vehicle and Traf?c Law Division Riverfront Of?ce Center, 3?1 Floor 1 101 South Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17104 Re: David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC -- v. Commonwealth of Department of Transportation No.: Dear Counsel: Enclosed please ?nd a time stamped copy oprpellants? Appeal from the Suspension of Certificate of Appointment as an Of?cial Emissions Inspection Station and Order Scheduling Hearing on Appeal. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact our of?ce. Paralegal /sne Enclosure Cemeseoweaite of? {?enesyleae?a Department of SEP {54 sea mace a? eager eeaasei Wil??ie 8: ram CGA Law Firm, CGA Professional Center, 135 N. George Street, York, PA 17401, 717.848.4900, Fax 717.843.9039, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY, David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC . Appellant, No.: V. Thursday. Augustza. 2014 3:51 pM 2014~s Commonwealth of 00300227 Department of Transportation, Appellee. APPEAL FROM THE SUSPENSION OF CERTIFICATE OF APPOINTMENT AS AN OFFICIAL EMISSIONS INSPECTION STATION AND NOW, this 2&9; day of August, 2014, comes Appellant, David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC 018 (?Appellant?), by and through their counsel, Christopher J. Reed, Esquire and the CGA Law Firm, P.C., and in support of this appeal from the suSpension of certi?cate of appointment as an of?cial emission inspection station respectfully avers as follows: 1. Appellant, David F. Ingram, is an adult individual who owns and operates Ingram?s Service Center, LLC, which is situated at 411 New Park Road, New Park, 17352. 2. The of?cial inspection station number for Ingram?s Service Center, LLC is EA21. 0083101004;l 1 3. On or about August 12, 2014, the Department of Transportation issued an Order of Suspension of Of?cial Emission InSpection Station, therin suSpending Appellant?s certi?cate of appointment for a cumulative period of two (2) years and assessed ?nes totaling $5,000.00, pursuant to Section 4724 of the Vehicle Code, effective August 12, 2014. A true and correct copy of the Order is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked as Exhibit 4. The suspension of Appellant?s certi?cate of appointment is unlawful, as Appellant was erroneously found to have (1) furnished, lent, given, sold or received a certi?cate of emission inspection without inSpection, and (2) fraudulently andfor improperly and carelessly kept records on a 1999 Lexus, VIN JT8BF28GOX0147240 by David Ingram, Operator- Issued stickerllM3-1866859. 5. Appellant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court stay the suSpending of the certi?cate of appointment as an of?cial emission inspection station pending a ?nal diSposition of the aforementioned appeal by the Court. WHEREFORE, Appellant David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC OIS respectfully requests that this Honorable Court allow them to take an appeal from the suspension of the certificate of appointment as an of?cial emission inspection station pending a ?nal disposition of the aforementioned appeal by the Court. {0087000421 0$~2 (won) 0 oonooywomn DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION .03- US August 12, 2014 David F. Ingram. Ingram's Service Center ?5.21 41 1 New Park Road New Park, PA 17352 ORDER OF SUSPENSION 0F OFFICIAL EMSSION SIATIDN You are: hornby noti?ed that your Corti?oate of as an Of?cial Emission Inspection Station is suspended, pursuant to Sootion 4724 oftho Vehicle Code. No vehicle: omission inspections may be: performed timing the Suspension. Pursuant to Departmental regx?a?ons, your Certi?cate of Appointment is Suspended for one year, and $2,500.00 dollar ?ne for ?nnish, loud, g?vo, sell or roocivo a certi?cate of omission inspection without inspoction and, one year, and $2,500.00 dollar ?ne for ?'audx?onx record keeping including the loose: o??onse?s of improper record keeping and careless record keeping on a. (1999 onus vm momsooxomm by David Ingram Operator ?ssoed sticker The susponsion{s) Ml] Ion consecutively, for a total Suspension of two (2) yoaro and 5,000.00 ?ne. This suspension is to run consecutivon with any Other mponsion(s) nnposed by the Deparonem for any violation considered separately. You are ordered to smondor to ?le bearer of this notice, who is a representative of the Doom-uncut of Transportation, your Cox??oato(s) of Appointme all mission inspection stickem and other related emission items. Your emission impaction equipment will be looked out from performing of?cial emissions testing for the duration of Ms suspension. Two (2) weeks prior to the oxpiration ofyour suspension, you may contaot your Quality Of?cer for reappoimmant. A comploto and thorough investigation may be conducted to determine if you are quali?ed for xoaopoinonent You have the right to appeal this Departmental Order of Suspension to the Count of Common Haas oftho County in which the above referenced inspection station is located, WITHIN THIRTY (39) DAYS 9F THE BATE OF THIS ORDER. If you do ?le an apme a signed and timootamped copy of the appeal must be sewed upon the Department at the mailing addzoso listed below. FILEG OF AN APHIAL DOES NOT STAY THE SUSPENSION. In order for your privilogos to be restored pending appeal, a signed Order of Summons from the Com dimming the Depamnont to stay the Suspension, must be served upon the Department at the: mailing address listed below. MING ABBRESS: Depamnent ofTransponntion, Chief Counsel?s O?ioo, Riverfront O?oo Center, I 101 Front Street, 3?d Floor, anti Harrisburg, 17104-2416. W6 ADDRESS: Sinooroly, Dopamnent of Transportation Riverfront Of?co Cantor 1 101 S. Front Strut, 3rd Floor Anita M. Wosko, Dirootor Harrisburg, PA 17104?24 16 Bureau ofMotor Vel?olos Vehicle Inspections I 1101 5. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 3.7104 717?78748?) em: ATTORNEY VERIFICATION I, ChristOpher J. Reed, counsel for the Petitioner, hereby af?rm that the facts contained in the foregoing Appeal ?om the Suspension of Certi?cate of Appointment as an Of?cial Emission InSpection Station are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. I further verify that I am making this veri?cation on behalf of Petitioner, David F. Ingram and Ingram?s Service Center, LLC OIS and that the information contained in the Appeal from the SuSpension of Certi?cate of Appointment as an Of?cial Emission Inspection Station is within my scope of knowledge and that the statements made are true and correct to my knowledge, information, and belief. This statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. ?4904 relating to unsworn falsi?cation to authorities. 135 North George Street York, PA 17401 717-848-4900 (telephone) 717-843?9039 (facsimile) creed@CGALaw.com Counsel for Appellant oesroomn IN THE COURT OF COMIMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY, MGM 45f, Sta?wt a Curfew rote?mo l? lxlC/?AN? (Print your name) . Vs- I I Driver?s License Auto Registration Appeal . comonwnamn OF .DEPARTWT OF BUREAU on DRIVER LICENSING ORDER SCHEDULING ON APPEAL - AND NOW, this he day of Aajwa ,20 14 a hearing is sohednled on the appeal of Petitioner for (jut-3, . 20 in! at 9:00 am. inthe Ceremonial Courtroom on the second ?10 or of the Administrative Center, 28 E. Market St, York, at which time testimony will be taken and argoment heard. A copy of this Order has been served on Appellant. It shall be Appellant?s responsibility to serve a cepy-of this Appeal, all attachments, and this Order on the attorney for the Commonwealth, at the following address: O?ce of Chief Counsel Vehicle and Traf?c Law Division River?ont Of?ce Center, 3er Floor 1 101 South Front Street Hattisburg', PA 17104?25 16 It Shall ?ltther be Appellant?s reSponsib?i?qr to ?le a Certi?cate of Setvice with the Prothonotary stating that service was made on the Commonwealth of By the Court Judge . J3, DEPARTMENT on TRANSPORTATION August 12, 2014 David F. Ingram Ingram?s Service Center 41 1 New Park Road New Park, PA 17352 ORDER OF SUSPENSION OF OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTION STATION You are hereby noti?ed that your Certi?cate of Appointment as an Official Emission Inspection Station is Suspended, pursuant to Section 4724 of the Vehicle Code. No vehicle emission inspections may be performed durin?g'the suspension, Pursuant to Departmental regulations, your Certi?cate oprpointrnent is suspended for one (1) year, and $2,5 00.00 dollar ?ne for ?rmish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of emission inspection without inspection and, one (i year, and $2,500.00 dollar ?ne for fraudulent record keeping including the lesser offenses of improper record keepincr and careless record keeping on a (l999 Lexus VIN rrsarzsooxomzm by David Ingram Operator _issued sticker IM3-1866859). The suspension(s) will run consecutively, for a total suspension of two (2) years and 5,000.00 ?ne. This suspension is to run consecutively with any other suspension(s) imposed by the Department for any violation considered separately. You are ordered to surrender to the bearer of this notice, who is a representative of the Department of Transportation, your Certi?cate(s) of Appointment, all emission inspection stickers and other related emission items. Your emission inspection equipment will be locked out from performing of?cial emissions testing for the duration of this suspension. Two (2) weeks prior to the expiration of your su5pension, you may contact your Quality Assurance Of?cer for reappointment. A complete and thorough investigation may he conducted to determine if you are quali?ed for reappointment. You have the right to appeal this Departmental Order of Suspension to the Court of Common Pleas of the County in which the above referenced inSpeotion station is located, WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. If you do file an appeal, a signed and time-stamped copy of the appeal must be served upon the Department at the mailing address listed below. FILING OF AN APPEAL DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY STAY THE SUSPENSION. In order for your privileges to be restored pending appeal, a signed Order of Supersedeas from the Court directing the Department to stay the suspension, must be served upon the Department at the mailing address listed below. MAILING ADDRESS: Department of Transportation, Chief Counsel?s Office, Riverfiont Office Center, 1 101 Front Street, 3rd Floor, and Han-isburg, PA 17104.2416. MAILING ADDRESS: Sincerely, Department of Transportation River?'ont Of?ce Center 1 101 s. Front Street, 3rd Floor Anita M. Waslco, Director Harrisburg, PA 17l04~24l6 Bureau of Motor Vehicles Vehicle Inspections I 1101 S. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17104 717087?2895 DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION July 29, 2014 David F. Ingram lngram's Service Center Linc-018i.E EAZI 411 New Park Road - New Park, PA 17352 ORDER OF SUSPENSION OF OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTION STATION You are hereby noti?ed that your Certi?cate of Appointment as an Of?cial Emission Inspection Station is suspended, pursuant to Section 4724 of the Vehicle Code. No vehicle emission inepections may be performed during the suspension. Pursuant to Departmental regulations, your Certi?cate of Appointment is suspended for one (1) year, and $2,500.00 dollar ?ne for furnish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of emission inspection without impaction and, one 1) year, and 32.5 00.00 dollar fine for ?auduient record keeping including the lesser offenses of improper record keepin and car 5 record keeping on a (1999 Lexus VIN by David Ingram OperatorHissued sticker inspection stickers and other related emissron items. Your emission inspection equipment will be locked out from performing of?cial emissions testing for the duration of this suspension. Two (2) weeks prior to the expiration of your suSpension, you may contact your Quality Assurance Of?cer for reappointment. A complete and thorough investigation may be conducted to determine if you are quali?ed for reappointment. . You have the right to appeal this Departmental Order of SuspensiOn to the Court of Common Pleas of the County in which the above referenced inspection station is located, WITHIN THIRTY (30) DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. If you do ?le an appeal, a signed and timeetamped copy of the appeal must be served upon the Department at the mailing address listed below. FILING OF AN APPEAL DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY STAY THE SUSPENSION. In order for your privileges to be restored pending appeal, a Signed Order of Supersedeas from the Court directing the Department to stay the suspension, must be served upon the Department at the mailing address listed below. MAILING ADDRESS: Department of Transportation, Chief Counsel?s Of?ce, Riverfront Of?ce Center, 1'1 01 Front Street, 3?1 Floor, and Harrisburg, PA 17104?2416. MAILING ADDRESS: Sincerely, Department of Transportation Chief Counsel ?5 Of?ce Riverfront Office Center 1101 S. Front Street, 3rd Floor Anita M. Wasko, Director Harrisburg, PA 17104?2416 Bureau of Motor Vehicles Vehicle Inspections 1101 S. Front Street I Harrisburg, PA 17104 7174874895 ?a DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION an a av.- . _e.c . we'- I - - David F. Ingram 41 1 New Park Road New Perle PA 1735?. (Ingtatn's Service Center Vehicle Inspection Division P. O. Box 69003 Harrisburg PA 17106-9003 Phone: (717) 787?2895 MECHANIC CERTIFIED MAIL: 7004251 0000141674864 MAIL DATE: July 29, 2014 NOTICE OF INTENT TO SUSPEND OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTOR You are hereby noti?ed that the Department intends to suspend your certi?cation as an Official Emission InSpector pursuant to Section of the Vehicle Code. If you are suspendedno vehicle emission inspections may be perfonned during a period of snapension. Pursuant to Department regulations, the Department intends to suspend your certification as an O?icial Emission InSpector for one (1) year, for furnish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of emission inspection without inspection and, one (1) year for fraudulent record keeping i ncluding the lesser offenses of improper record keeping and careless record keeping on 210999 Lexus VIN by David Ingram Operator ?issued sticker INS-1866859). 'I?he suspension(s) is to run consecutive [y for a total suspension of two (2) years. This suSpension is to run consecutively with any other suspension(s) imposed by the Department for any violation considered separately. Credit for your suspension term will not begin until your certification. card is surrendered to the Department. You may contact your Quality Assurance O?cer to surrender your certification card or you may mail your certi?cation card to the Vehicle Inspection Division, Post O?ice Box 69003, Harrisburg, PA I7106~9003i You have a right to request a hearing on the above referenced sanction(s) under 2 ??501a508 (relating to general rules of administrative practice and procedure of administrative agencies); 1 Pa. Code Part II {relating to general rules of administrative practice and procedure) and 67 Pa. Code Chapter- 491 (relating to administrative practice and procedure) by submitting a written request for a hearing within 30 days of the above mail date to the Administrative Docket Clerk, Office of Chief Counsel, 400 North Street, 9th Floor, Harrisburg, PA 17120-0096. A copy of this letter shall accompany the request. THIS IS YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD IN THIS MATTER. IF YOU FAIL TO REQUEST A HEARING ON THE ABOVE REFERENCED 30 DAYS OF THE MAIL DATE OF THIS YOU WILL HAVE WAIVED YOUR RIGHT TO CHALLENGE THE SUSPENSION. ADDITIONALLY, THE ABOVE SANCTIONG) WILL ALSO BE FINAL AND YOUR ERTIFICATION AS AN OFFICIAL EMISSION INSPECTOR WILL BE SUSPENDED EFFECTIVE August 29, 2014. Sincerely, Anita M. Waslco. Director Bureau of Motor Vehicles 113911 dleh DTSE Postage 5 Ceniis'cd Fae Postmark Return Recalpi Fee Hem (Endorsement Required} Delivery Foo {Endorsemaal Requhed} Tom! Poslage Fees Sent To Station name: lngram's Service Center He 013i? EMISSION OVERT Review: date: 419m York County El SAFETY COVERT VIOLATION SUMMARY 319/1 3 1999 Lexus Failed Emissions By Tech mSteven Boyer) For Several Codes. Vehicle Was Passed 3113/13 By Tech ill-David lngram 0 Communication And issued Sticker luereesese. HEARING David Ingram [owner tech) related he remembered vehicle, it failed and they replaced 2 sensors and he was driving die vehicle resetting the monitors and the vehicle blew out his scan tool, he sent the scan tool back for repairs. He then plugged the vehicle in and couldn?t get it to communicate and was frustrated from whetjust happened and the inspection and gave it a sticker. He realizes now after a cooler head prevails he could have given the vehicle a waiver. He was just frustrated. Work orders attached showing the vehicle was repaired along with both VlR's RECOMMENDED STATION PENALTY concurrent El consecutive one (1) year, and $2,500.00 dollar fine for furnish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of emission inspection without inspection and, one (1) year, and $2,500.00 dollar ?ne for ??audulent record keeping including the lesser offenses of improper record keeping and careless record keeping RECOMMENDED MECHANIC PENALTY concurrent Cl consecutive one (1) year for furnish: lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of emission inspection without inspection and, one (1) year for fraudulent record keeping including the lesser offenses of improper record keeping and careless record keeping approved Signature: disapproved (see below) I I I I AECHANIC NUMBER STATION NUMBER EAZI STICKER NUMBER STAT NAME CITY COUNTY STAT BUS APPT STAT SERVICE CENTER LLC TOT SUSP NEW PARK ROAD TOT PARK SAFETY AUDIT ZIP YORK IM APQT OWNER DAVID EM SUSP IND SUSPENSION: SAFETY EMISSION MAIL INwaw RESTORE MAIL DATE-- MAIL CITY- SUSPBN MAIL 219"? STICKERS PRINT INSPECTION MECHANIC NUMBER -- STAT NAME CITY CERTIFICATION EXPIR CANCEL DA FAIL DAT- CHK DISS--IN CANCEL DUPS-- DUP MECE TYD-- BR RN L.R DT- EMISSION .ATION DAT- ZXPIR CANCEL RBCS wan 3' EN RN LTR 1ND-- DUP DATE-- EMIS RN IND-- STICKERS STATION NUMBER 5.1521 SYSTEM INQUIRY STICKER NUMBER COUNTY NAME 'iDAle INGRAM ADDR- ZND ADDR- ZIP YORK RECD STOP CODES-- LICEN CLAS--C SEC 01 CHK a: UL EXPIR 04/07/18 BIRTH uArz--uu SUSPENSION: SAFETY EMISSIONS RESTORE EFFECTIVE ~v may: I (1.97) COMMONWEALTH OF DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION Station Name 3121 Ingraun's Servioc Center LLC Hearing Dam/Tm May 30, 2014 2:61.5th mammal Hearing Type: Safety Emissions Station Authority David F. Imam Mechanic (Put none, if ?n'ls to appcw) (If mochar?c hearing only) Address Hem-Eng Examiner. Gail Koch (Please Print) /Statezzi Insp. 9mm Sup. 3111me Date of Violation 4-9? I 3 Present for hearing: {Ifthose required fail to appear, State so a?cr name) Bill QAO mm mm: (For Mom Testifying) m- Station Authorityrreahnician Station Name: Title (For Whom Tcs??dw mm? Tid? (For Whom Tm NW Tim: {Far Whom Tcs??ring) Final Department Action: of Violation(s) by Station: TO BE COMPLETED BY CENTRAL OFFICE ONLY-410 NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE No Action Impose a Sanction Sanction(s): DEPARTMENT AUTHORITY: CONCURRENT CONSECUTIVE TOTAL SANCTIOMS) Violatio?s) by Mechanic: 5311260113): CONCURRENT CONSECUTIVE TOTAL SAch-Ioms) DATE: (Signature) NOTE: READ THIS TO THOSE IN ATTENDANCE BEFORE PROCEEDIN G. This heating is an informal Depart:an hearing, which we axe pursuant to Depart:an regulations, 67 Pa. Code Section 175.5 1 as a result of alleged violations of the Deparonem's insPeetion regulations. This headng is not an administrative subject to the Administrative Code. ?Ifhese proceedingsmaynot be u?ansoribed. ofevidenee do not apply, and all relevantevideneew?l be considered. Therefore, objections will not be heard The State Trooper or Gmage Inspector will ptesenthis evidence ?rst. Then, the station owner andlor the manager and the mechanic may present evidence. Next, I will as]: questions of the trooper, the mechanic, the manager and/or the station owner. We have allowed half-hour! Minutes! Home hour! mtwto hours for this heating; so, please be bn'ef TESTIMONY: QAO Bill mad into the report dated 4/9/13. MECHANICS TESTIMONY: David Ingram-? What am said is pretty much what happened. I wem ?nough the test with the other guy, he tested it and failed it Wilh multiple codes, reewmhed codes, and saw it neededtwoOZsensors, andhadthetechto do thedtivecyeles. He had the soantool along with him during the do; cycle, the scan tool went to blue semen locked up, so he drove the car back in. We plugged the vehicle back into the analyzetithadno communication, audit askedifiwamedto deal-?12 andretryso [retried once. Then I didaF? which was continue with communications. I put the sticker number in which I found out later at the inspection meetingthatl Wego to class and learnhow to test tit; correctweyat out-shop wade bookbecanselhave sincethe garage meeting to askwhat to deatthehotline." cm! TATION OWNER MA AG SI MTIGATING EVENTS. IF ANY: RESPONSE TO WIGATING EVENTS: IF ANY: EABI INFORMATION FROM OWNER (IF OWNER IS DIFFERENT PERSON THAN MECHANIC) 018# y) Are you nonnally present at the business when inspections are being performed? Ifnot, do you designate someone to act in your place and if so who? Were you present at the time of these alleged violations? Ifnot, was anyone designated to be in charge, and if so, who? Did you or your designee know that the actions taken by the mechanic may have cons?tuted a violation of the inspection regulations? Were you or your designer: awam that the alleged viola?ons were occurring and if so, why did you allow them to om? Did you have any policies or procedmes in place at the time of the alleged violations that should have prevented this ?ow counting, and if so what were they? What steps, if any, have been taken to prevent an incident like this from occurring in the future? 018$! INFORMATION FROM memo (m MECHANIC IS DIFFERENT PERSON THAN OW) momma NAME David 13mm OPERATORS 1. Is the owner normally present at the business when impactions are performed? It not, does he dosignate someone to act in his place and if so who? Yes. I am always there. 2. Was the owner or his regular designeo present at the time of those alleged violations? Ifnot, was anyone designated to be in charge, and if so who? Yes. 3. Did you know that the actions you were taking as a mechanic may havo constituted a violation of the impaction regulations? Ifso, why did you proceed? No. 4- W33 the owner, manager or dcsignco aware that tho allong violations were occum?ng and if so, Why did they allow them to occur?Did?Ot know- 5' Did the mc?m given by the owner or his designee contribute to the alleged violations? If so what were the instructions? Ownerffech 6. Were any business policies or procedures in place at the time of the alleged violations? Would these policies or procedures have prevented this alleged violation? If so what were they? No. If I would have known in March what I learned at the gamgc meeting in April this would not have been. What steps, if any, have been taken to prevent this ?om coming in the ?xture? 'I-?hore is no which is no commicationspasscd in our shop. 0113;? WI HEARING FINDING 0F FACTS: The followingitcm covered: Furnish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of inspection without inspection and ?andulent record keeping including the lesser o?'enses ofimpxoperrecord keeping and careless record keeping. (On March 9, 2013 impector David f. Inng a 1999 Lexus VIN #nsonzsooxommo and issued inSpec?on to the vehicle with no communications. Station Authority/Inspector David Ingram Claim to this hearings examiner that after the initial test on 319(13 when it failed with mx?tiplc codes {See Attachment they (both hiinselfand the otherer replaced two 02 sensors (See Attachment not). After the repairs were made the codes were cleared. The Vehicle returned to the Station on 3!13f13, odometer reading showed 141 miles driven. At this time the vehicle were not ready for testing so he had the other inspector do the drive cycle to set the monitors. Inspector Ingram stated that during antithescen tool went to a blue screen and locked up. It was at this time that the other inspector drove the vehicle back to the station. Inspector Ingram stated that during the test of3f13113 the 1999 hams would not communicate. He stated that he nied to get it to communicate one time byhitting the F12 button on his anabrzer to retry, and when it did not? This hearings examiner questioned insocctm-Ingmm ifhe did any troubleshooting on the Lexus after it did not communicate as to why it one not communicating. Inspector Logan: stated that he had just received his emission license in 2/13 and did not remember the proceduxes from class on what he was summed to do when a vehicle did not communicate, but he did clean the pins on the vehicles DLC and then hit the may heron on the analyzer. This hearings another questioned inepcctor Igtam if the vehicle was ready for testing prior to the second test and he stated he had no way of because the scan tool was blown and had to be sent out for rcpaim This beatings examiner questioned impector Inginmifhe hcdid not. This hearings ifheknewtherewas ahotlinc available to call ifhe had ques?ons about inopections, and he Stated yes he knew that there was a hot line, but he was ?nsnamd and wanted; get the customer out of his hair so at the time he did not think of calling the hot line. InSpector Ingram was advised in the future not to pass any vehicles wi?z no communications Milieu: authorization from the hot line. and prior to calling he $11on check the #16 pin forpower and #4 5 pin for mounds. Inspector Ingram was also advised not to clearcodesn?errcpairsaremade but to lettitelightgo out onits oona?er thevehiclerocognizes made, clearing codes causes readiness. Attachment A-l Infonmtion obtained from the W120 for tests perfonned at OBIS EAZI Ingmm?s Service Center on the 1999 Lexus VIN Attachment A-2 (Invoice #12355 for inspection of 1999 E3300 Lexus from 018 Ingam's Service Comer) HWG SIGNATURE: Gail 530144 0A0 3m 018 EA21, lngrams Semi 09 Center 01.0 Cheating I 1 - ?3223 63/09/2013 3T85F2360X0147240 HSL8223 osmzzoxa LLC INRGAMS SERVICE CENTER WK022079 5298367290 03,113/2013 16:36:03 6 f. i 0A0 81!: 03/09/2013 deiomze .3 0318/2023 16:50:23 a 53300 55366 161565 018 - EA21. lngrams Service Center DLC Cheating 161705 P1153 AirlFue! Ratio Response Malfunction {Bank 2 Sensor 1) P1155 - AiriFueI Ratio Sensor Heater Circuit Maifunction (Bank 1 Sensor 1) P1354 - Variabie Valve Timing System Fault I I f? mm 3511mean - lnvonce 411NewPardeBom?l? . New Put, PA 17352 Date 7 31132013 12356 Bill To Special Wamc?ws Tulsa. Vehicle Year TechRep Team License Mileage [m 300 i 1999 LW. Quantity Item Code Description Price Each Amount I LighIDuty Vehicle 29.95 29.95: 1 Examining Bmissims Tasting 29.95 29.95'1? my I. ?Dmyvaick 29.95 29.95: 1 WW 02 Sensor 79.31 79.3IT I WAL 25054054 02 Sm 165.81 165.31? 1 labor: 1b Can! Light Trunklabw/Mow 72.92 Sales Tax 6.00% 24.47 1 Mt:me madness IhezeisNO W, soldhezcm?msem?cby .m?t?cm WNW Phone if Fax No an electrical or 717.993.3770 717?993-0975 specialarderpms. Total 343135 DRIVE CLEAN April 30. 2014 Certi?ed Mail 7010 0290 0002 3096 4490 Subject: Depamnental Hearing David F. Ingram lngram?s Service Center LLC 411 New Park Road New Park, PA 17352 From Gail Koch A Departmental hearing has been scheduled for May 30, 2014 2:00 PM. The hearing win he hem at: Emissions Team 5340 Jayoee Avenue Suite Harrisburg. PA 17112 017-565-7500 Directions From a?l 81 North Take the Paxtonia Exit Road Forks, keep right Allentown 22W. Continue on Jonastown Rams-22w Turn right on Jaycee Avenue, tan stone building on the left Suite E, Parsons Logo is on the door. PET 5-01 979 East Park Drive, Han?isburg. PA 17111 v1.1 0130/04 DEPARTMENT on . (332.5333 tel $39. .2353 David F. Ingram (Open - lngram's Service Center LLC - OIS 41 1 New Park Road New Park, PA 17352 Dear Sir: The report(s) of April 9, 2013, received from the Quality Assurance Of?cer indicates violation(s) of: Furnish, lend, give, sell or receive a certi?cate of inspection without inepection and fraudulent record keeping including the lesser offenses of record keping and careless record keeping. (On March 9, 2013 inspector David F. Ingram Operator inSpected a 1999 Lexus VIN and issued inspection sticker IM3-1866859 to the vehicle with no communication). As a result of the above mentioned report(s), a Departmental heating has been scheduled. The attached memo from the Safety and Emissions Team indicates the date, time and location of the hearing. Failure to appear at the appointed time will be considered a waiver ofyour right to a hearing, and thus, a determination as to whether or not to suspend your Emission Inspection Station Certi?cate of Appointment and/or Emission Inspector Certi?cation will be made in your absence. In cases where the certi?cate appointee was not present at the station at the time of the violation, but had placed a manager or supervisor in charge of the operation of the station, it is important that the . manager or supervisor appear at the Departmental heann g. ALL SHOULD BRING THEIR OPERATORS LICENSE MECHANIC CERTIFICATION CARD TO THE HEARING. If you have any questions, please contact the Vehicle Inspection Division, P. O. Box 68697, Harrisburg, PA 17106-8697, or telephone (717) 7874895. Sincerely, Anita M. Wasko, Director Bureau of Motor Vehicles Vehicle Inspection Division I 1101 S. Front Street I Harrisburg, PA 33104 7174874895 Station name: lngram?s Service Center He BMSSION OVERT EA21 El SAFETY El COVERT Review: date: 4/9f13 York County VIOLATION SUDMARY 3/9! 13 1999 Lexus VlNi.i jt8bi28G0xOl47240 failed emissions Boyer) for several codes. Vehicle was passed 3/13/13 by tech as no communication and issued sticker M31866859. by tech Steven avid Ingram) HEARING TESTIMONY David Ingram (owner tech) related he remembered vehicle, it failed and they replaced 2 sensors and he was diiving The vehicle resetting the monitors and the vehicle blew out his scan tool, he sent the scan tool back for repairs. He then plugged the vehicle in and couldn't get it to communicate and was frusn-ated ?ora what just happened and f7'd the inspection and gave it a sticker. He realizes now a?er a cooler head prevails he could have given the vehicle a waiver. He was just ?'ustrated. Work orders attached showing the vehicle was repaired along with both RECOMMENDED STATION PENALTY comment consecutive umishing Fraud - hearing RECOMMENDED MECHANIC PENALTY El concurrent Cl consecutive [1 approved Signature: disapproved (see below) INSP INSPECTION MECHANIC NUMBER STAT NANE CITY CERTIFICATION EXPIR CANCEL RECERTIFICATION DATE-- MAIL DATE CHK CANCEL IND- DUPS- SAF DUP UTE-- MECH TYP-- ER SUSP IND- RN LTR DT- RN EMISSIONS: CERTIFICATION DATE EXPIR CANCEL DATE RECERTIFICATION ~10/05/12 .0/05/14 MAIL DATE-- EMIS DUP DATE- RN LTR IND-- EMIS RN STICKERS PRINT STATION NUMBER SYSTEM INQUIRY STI CKER NUMBER COUNTY -DAVID INGRAM ADDR -- 2ND ADDR-- ZIP YORK STOP CODES-- REED LICEN SEC ADD 0L CHK DIG-- 0L EXPIR 04/07/14 WISSIONS SUSPENSION: SAFETY RESTORE PEND- - EFFECTIVE DATE SUSPEN INSPECTION MECHANIC NUMBER STAT NAME CITY CERTIFICATION EXPIR CANCEL RECERTIFICATION DATE 12/18/13 MAIL DATE -- CHK DIGS--BO CANCEL IND -- DUPS- SAF MECH 8R SUSP IND- RN ITR DT-- RN EMISSIONS: DATE --03/13/12 EXPIR CANCEL DATE- -U4/02/l4 DATEV-- MAIL DUPS- EMIS DUE DATE- RN LTR EMIS RN IND- TI CKERS PRINT SYSTEM STAT ION NUMBER INQUIRY STICKER NUMBER COUNTY --STEVEN CARROLL EOYER ADDR- 2ND ADDR-- ZIP CODE-- 67 YORK STOP CODES-- RECD LICEN SEC ADDR-- 0L CHK 1315*- 0L EXPIR 03/26/15 EIRTH - SUSPENSION: RESTORE EFFECTIVE DATE SUSPEN SAFETY EMISSIONS INSP I I I I STICKER NUMBER COUNTY MECHANIC NUMBER STATION NUMBER STAT NAME CITY STQT BUS STAT TOT TOT SAFETY AUDIT SUSP IM APPT DATEum?w?Ol/o4/12 IM susp IND MAIL MAIL MAIL MRIL ZIP-H STICKERS PRINT APPT SERVICE CENTER LLC NEW PARK ROAD PARK ZIP YORK OWNER DAVID SUSPENSION: SAFETY EMISSION RESTORE EFFECTIVE SUSPEN PET 2?01 v2.0 Official Emissions Inspection 12/11/05 Station Investigation Report Station Name lngram?s Service Center LLC 018 Number EA21 Street Address 411 New Park Rd County York Cityand Zip Code New Park Phone Number 717-993-3770 Start: Miles Driven: I Start: Travel Time: Start: Audit Time: End: End: End: Type of Report DLC Cheating - Faulty Inspections 1? Furnishing Stickers C3 Appointment Cl Cancellation E3 Reappointment E3 Suspension My; E21 Investigation Other Sticker Reconciliation Previous Balance: 1 Stickers Issued: Stickers Voided: Received: I Stickers Missing: Stickers Stolen: Total to Audit: 1 Stickers Destroyed: Stickers Used: Last Sticker Audited: I Sticker Balance: Stickers on Site: 3 Violations Indicated: :3 Administrative xRecord E3 Vehicle Related Other Comments: On 319m a 1999 Lexus VIN JT88F2860X0147240 failed emissions by tech ?for several codes. The vehicle was then passed on 3/13 by tech as a no communication and issued sticker 1 M31 868859. Owner and techFrelated that he remembers the vehicle. The vehicle failed and they replaced 2 02 sensors and he was nving the vehicle resetting the monitors and the vehicle blew out his scan tool, he sent the scan tool back for repairs. He then plugged the vehicle in and couldn't get it to communicate and was frustrated from what just happened and 1?7?d the inapection and gave it a sticker. He realizes now after a cooler head prevails that he could have given the vehicle a waiver. He was just frustrated. Work orders attached showing the vehicle was repaired along with both VlR?s. Station Representative: Date: Number: 63421 Date: Dept. Representative: I hereby verify that the information so: fonh herein was compiled in full accordance with cstablishod procedures and is true and correct to the best ofmy in?ammation. and belief: This veri?cation is made subject to the penalties of? 18 $54904. relating to unswom falsi?cation to authorities. Inspection Station Interview Report v1.101H4i09 PET 10-04A Station Owner/Station Authority Questionnaire Station Name Ingram Service Center LLC 013 Number can Address . m. i- - County City/Zip New Park, PA 17352 phone (717) 993.3 770 - Interviewed: Owner at?? . ?elf: Eilomi?tgt?hes?o. . i 311 matesitdc'hm'cia' ?be ?o 2 . . .ervthe station owner/manager normally pr esent when inspections are being conducted? Name: James Waltemyer 2. If the station ownerfmanager is not present, who is in charge in their absence? [1 3. Was the station ownerfmanager or their regular designee present at the time of the alleged violations? Yes No 4. Were you aware that the actions being taken may have constituted a violation of the inspection Yes No regulations? Slfyou were aware that the action being taken may have constituted a violation, why did you proceed? i 6. Was the station owner/manager or designee aware that the alleged violations were occurring? 1 [3 Yes No to occur? 7. If the station ownerfmanager or designee was aware that th alleged violations were occuring, why did they allow them infomtation and Station Signaturczl Have reviewed censidcrs whether or not to impose pena 8. Did actions by the station ownerfmanager or designee contribute to the alleged violations? Explain. Yes No Ovmerwes the tech. ?m 9. Were any policies or procedures in place that would have prevented the alleged violations? Explain. Yes No 10. What steps, if any, will be taken to prevent this from occuring in the future? When there is no communication he will call the hot line to see who: procedure he should use it may be used as of?cial statement when Date: 75%; M92013 Number. Date: 63421 ubject to the penalties of IS Pails. $54904, relating was compiled in full accordance with the established to unswom falsi?cation to authorities ll'vl procedures and is true and correct to the best of my knowledch If Wit. did i ll Per 10.049 Inspection Station Interview Report v1.2 03fl9f10 Vehicle Inspection Questionnaire Station Name Ingrams Service Center LLC 018 Number EAZI Address 41 I New Park Road County York City/Zip New Park. PA 17352 MM phone 17139933770 Interviewed: Station . 1. Why was a sticker issued when no inspection had been conducted by a certified inspector? 2. Explain the defects found during the rednepection of the vehicle and how the failing items were missed during your initial inspection. 3. Were all required measurements taken (brakes, tires, baiijoints)? If no, explain. I: Yes CI No 4. Bxpiain the difference(s) in the readings taken during the initial inspection vs. the re~inspection. 5.Explain how you exceeded the number of inSpections permitted per hour while doing a complete and MA proper inspection. 6. How did you make the determination regarding required repairs? MA 7. Why did you perform repairs on the vehicle-(s) without owner authorization? 8. "Why was the DLC accessibiefable to communicate on the initial test, but not the retest? only) 9. Why do the mileage readings recorded during the emission inspection and safety inspection differ? 10. Considering the customer?s county or vehicle model year, why were incorrect UM tests performed? 1 I. Did actions by the station owner/manager or designee contribute to the alleged violations? Explain. Yes Owner was the tech. '3 N0 Station Representative Signature: I Have reviewyg?higgu f?cisLsemesawwhw Date: I 4(9/2013 I more was compiled in full accordance with the established procedures infomao?on and brief: This veri?cation is made subject to the penalties of 13 mos. 554904, relating to unswom falsi?cation to authorities and is true and correct to the best of my kno?lcd?LI/l' EM I) v1.2 per radio Inspection Station Interview Report Stickers Questionnaire Station Name W- M, 015 Number Address County City/Zip New Park, PA 27352 Phone (717) 993-3 770 2. How did you. gain possession of the altered, forged, stolen or counterfeit stickems)? 3. Why wasn't the sticker completed and affixed immediately upon completioo of the inspection? 4. Why was the safety sticker issued before the emission inspection was conducted? S.How did yen calculate the sticker expiration? During business hours Yes No After business hours Yes No 6. Are the station's stickers under lock and key? If no, explain. Yes No Not 7. Who has access to the station's stickers? 8. Who veri?es your Sticker orders upon receipt? 9. Any previous counseling regarding sticker issues? Ifyes, explain or attach documentation. Yes considers whether or not to impose pen No 10. Did actions by the station owner/manager or designee contribute to the alleged violations? Explain. Yes Owner was the tech No Station Representative Signamrc: I Have reviewed imexoe used as official statement when Date: WM 5 I Number: Date: 63421 4i9!2013 I herby verify :11 compiled in full accordance with the established procedures and is true and correct to the best of my knowledge! information and one This veri?cation is made subject to the penalties of 18 354904, relating to unswom falsi?cation to authorities 3' i i Order Day $11 Date 3- ??33 Waiter or Technician: Dave James Tim Steve Rick Customer Information: iin??g/ 731m La?ncisgy Name: Address 2 Email: Horn: 5% - Cell Vehicie Information: 01d Mileage: (930 New Mileage Hal f) 6 5" Vin Year .- Make Model 4 my: 827.3 Expo )Ilzmq' . PA meme: M. tho: Old Sticker 1M 2 giggly New Sticker 1M Safety Info . Insurance Company Gr EKG 9050? ?gr?WW. EXP 3 OidSticker? A12. 0422.743 NewS?ckem 593/33550 39 P: PASS R: REPAR NOT APPLICABLE Pre Raad Test WM Ham? Wind-shield- ?Wipa'Bi-ndca' 9/12 rm 2mm [funSiynbUFKK?F 412.4% ligms?kcmocalighm? 5mm M?hdjm MW 'rm'rmancpa; m? uru?fg; 7542 ?.131! 4 Manankzlin: Brah?mcs /Bnkx:Fk?dT Fromm Mm? infmm imam ?in-m a Wom?a?lm L/m ms:ng Caucasian Poe-l Mm Pf} 32m EEfnfrad *1 Inn \gml? f3? r113 (rumINGRAMS SERVICE CENTER LLC I nvonce 411New Park Rd Box#17 New Park PA17352 Date 3H3f2013 12366 Bill To Special Vehicle Year Tecthep Terms License Mileage Lexus 300 1999 1W. Quantity Item Code Description Price Each Amount 1 Light Dilly Light Duty Vehicle 29.95 29.95T 1 Emission Emissions Testing 29. 95 29.9ST 1 Light Duty light Duty Vehicle 29.95 29.951? 1 WAL25024339 02 Sensor 79.31 79.311? 1 WAL 25034054 02 Sensor 165.81 165.817: 1 Labor 1b Car! Light Truck Labor/Mower 72.92 72.92'1? Sales Tax 6.00% 24.47 Any man?es on products There is NO wananty, sold here are those; made by Mb? 13 Not covered by express or implied on any the manufacmrem ?mm used or consignment Phone Fax No returns on elechical or 717-993-3770 717.993.0975 specialch pans. $49136 I OF HICLE EMISSIONS INSPECTI REPORT 08?? VEHICLE INFORMATION Year: 1999' Make: LEX US odel: 533 00 VIN: W83F2-SGOX0147240 Engirfe Size: 3000 Cylinders: 6 3:23:16? 3413613353 ELZELHW gmm. 532::me 0 County: YORK Record 003933 EMISSIONRELATED INFORMATION Bulletin 79574 Bulletin 24363 Bulletin 24342 Bulletin 2425?? Bulletin 24273 Bulletin 2427?. Bulletin 24996 Bulletin 2493] Bulletin 124963 Bulletin 124310 Bulletin it: 125060 Bulletin 241286 Bulletin 24299 Vehicle tested in accordance with Pa. Code Title 67. Chapter 177 EMISSIONS INSPECTION STATION STATION: EAEI STATION NAME: mews SERVICE CENTER LLC. INSPECTOR NAME: STEVEN BOYER . I ADDRESS 41 I PARK R939 EQUIPMENT: wxozzow NEW PARK. PA 17332-0000 SOFTWARE VERSION, 0891 PHONE: (71 3993.3 770 VEHICLE EMISSIONS INSPECTION QUESTIONS: For addizional Inspector's information. please contact the Customer Hotline a! (30m 2 55.0921 mama.?- COWONWEALTH OF VIN: VEHICLE EMISSIONS INSPECTION REPORT Ill} TITLE: 5293367290 VEHICLE INFORMATION Year: 1999 Make: LEXUS Modci: E5300 VIN: IT Engine Size: 3000 Cylinders: 6 Odomotcr: 0161705 GVWR: 0 Estimated Test License: Inspection Typo: RETEST Weight: 0 Connt's': YORK Record 003992 EMISSIONS CONTROL SYSTEMS INSPECTION Air Inj. System: WA Camiytio Convener: WA Fuel Cap Integrity: PASS EGR System: NM. Bvaporative Control MA PCV System: WA Fuel 11'1ch Rostrictor: NM OBI) EMISSIONS INSPECTION MIL BULB K0130: PASS OBD FAULT CODE RESULT MA MIL BULB KOER: PASS OBD READINESS RESULT: NA MIL COMMAND STATUS: OBI)wade CHECK RESULT: NM OVERALL TEST RESULTS: PASSED Emissions Control Systems VimaVchtiona! Inspection: PASS OBD Emissions lnspootion: NM Sticker: IM31866859 TIN: 857488027990 Based on the information gathered during an attempt to perform on On Board Diagnostic test, NO Signai was available from the On Board Diagnostic computer system. This vehicie should produce a signal from the On Board Diagnostic computer system. This vehicle needs to have the above problem corrected prior to next vear?s cm issions inspection. RETAIN THIS DOCUMENT FOR YOUR RECORDS. Vehicle testod in acoordanoo'with Pa. Code Title 67. Chapter 177 EMISSIONS INSPECTION STATION smnom EAZI STATION NAME: INGRAMS SERVICE CENTER LLC. INSPECTOR NAME: DAVID mom?: ADDRESS: 41: NEW PARK ROAD NEW PARK. PA 17352-0000 ?(023079 I I- PHONE: (717)993o770 ARE VERSION :97 VEHICLE EMISSIONS INSPECTION QUESTIONS: Fer add izional I a] n. 1 ?4 :n?F?nI-mo?nn Al?n?h a! Pun- rho-nah- ??l?nol .. ?Ix: COWONWEALTH OF macro EMISSIONS mm mm REPORT Test Date/Tim 8: 0310912013 03:10 VEHICLE INFORMATION Year: I 999 Mako: LEXUS Model: 53300 VIN: Engine Size: 3000 Cylinders: 6 Odometer: 0161565 GVWR: 0 Esrimatcd Test Licensc: HSL3223 Inspection Type: Weight: 0 County: YORK Record 003983 EMISSIONS CONTROL SYSTEMS INSPECTION Air inji System: NM Catalytic Converter: NM Fuel Cap Integrity: PASS EGR System: NIA Bvaporativc Control System PCV 33stem: MA Fuel Inlet WA OBD EMISSIONS INSPECTION MIL BULB KOEO: PASS OBI) FAULT CODE RESULT FAILED MIL BULB KOER: PASS OED READINESS RESULT: PASS . MIL COMMAND STATUS: FAILED CHECK RESULT: FAILED DTC Codes: P0125 P0420 P3153 P1155 91354 Only the ?rst five will Print check the 0813 for additional OVERALL TEST RESULTS: FAILED Emissions Control Systems WWI/Functional InSpection: PASS OBD Emissions Inspection: FAI LEI) TIN: RETAIN THIS DOCUMENT FOR USE ON REJNSPECTION. RETURN THE VEHICLE TO THE SAME STATION WITHIN (30) DAYS FOR ONE (2) FREE RETEST. This vohic it: has failed the emissions inspection. REPAIRS SHOULD BE MADE TO EITHER PASS 0R QUALIFY FOR A WAIVER. All emissions related repairs perfonncd must be documented by the inspection station. This inspection report, Emissions Related Raga}? Data form and copies of the repair receipts must be made available to the inspection station arthetime of re?inspemion. in order for a vohicle to receive a tho foliowi ng requirements must be met. I. REPAIR WORK MUST BE APPROVED BY A CERTIFIED REPAZR TECHNICIAN OR OTHER COMMONWEALTH APPROVED INSPECTOR. . Emissions related repair expenditures must have been at least $150.00 . Copies ofthe. repair receipts for emissions related repairs must be provided to the inspection Station. Repairs were porfonned no earlier than 60 days prior to the initial . Repairs must be appropriate and related to the cause of failure. wows: Vehicle tested in accordance with Pa. Code Title 67. Chapter 177 EMISSIONS INSPECTION STATION STATION: STATION NAME: INGRAMS SERVICE CENTER LLC. INSPECTOR NAME: STEVEN BOY ER A 4 . NEW PARK RQAD EQUIPMENT: wxozzms: NEW pm PA 1735243000 SOFTWARE VERSION. 08,1 PHONE: (717)993?3770 VEHICLE INSPECTION QUESTIONS: For additional info rmatiort please contact the Customer Hot} inc at (800) 2650921. Signature: QAO - Bil! l' .- OIS - EAzi, Ingrams Service Center DLC Cheating 3' 2 r33; ?Fag .- .- a 13mg? 22123:: RE 1.4L- 5?1. .. tf .. 1.:3311, J. 2. . HSL8223 03/13/2013 sum-1.3 on 0 4L: WRGAMS SERVICE CENTER LLC INRGAMS SERVICE CENTER LLC WK022079 5298367290 03fl3l2013 16:36:03 8 OIS - EA21, ingrams Service Center 0A0 - an: DLC Cheating nm; a fme?o. x6}. . 3.4a 161565 esaoo" ., w. wow. 1?999 I do 2625 5 9310922013 63' 5 Nu 7 1 6 {in E5300 LEXUS 23 a 1999 50: I 16 Fuel Control Below Threshold Bank 1 Cooiant Temperature for Closed Loo P0125 - Powenrain. insufficien us money System Eff P0420 - Powertrain. Catal (Bank 2 Sensor 1 (Bank 1 Sensor 1) [On Response Malfunct :roui Sensor P1153 - Air/Fuei Ratio P1155 - Ai lFueI Rat {on cuit Malfunct io Sensor Heater Cir System Fault mung P1354 - Variabie Valve CONSIDERATION OF POINT ASSESSMENT IN LIEU OF SUSPENSION . STATION I smnow WE HEARING DATE 8: Date Ewdence of proper by the station to at . proper has demonstrated the station . not present at time of the no other OmerlManager to at the time of the violation 5 A The station committed the violation 8 . station in the The station had of the violation 3 . station ownerlmaneger is proper? record does not ownerfmanager reviewed inspection records that wouid have indicated a 3 occurred. ownerlmanager have had of the vioiation . who committed the had access to certi?cates of who the on(s was in the activities at the time the 3 occurred. station ownerfmanager is responsible for ensuring that are certi?ed to ns. [3 for reporting the station or discontinuance of business. Other (specify):